- 8.8/10(12 votes)
#1 - Mr. Scratch
S10:E210 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Breen Frazier - 8.6/10(8 votes)
#2 - The Capilanos
S13:E170 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Erica Messer - 8.5/10(14 votes)
#3 - Lauren
S6:E180 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Breen Frazier - 8.5/10(8 votes)
#4 - Elliott's Pond
S12:E60 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Erica Messer - 8.4/10(15 votes)
#5 - Mosley Lane
S5:E160 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Erica Messer - 8.3/10(14 votes)
#6 - The Lesson
S8:E100 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Janine Sherman Barrois - 8.3/10(11 votes)
#7 - Blood Relations
S9:E200 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Breen Frazier - 8.2/10(13 votes)
#8 - Gatekeeper
S9:E70 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Erica Messer - 8.1/10(17 votes)
#9 - Heathridge Manor
S7:E190 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Sharon Lee Watson - 8.1/10(11 votes)
#10 - A Beautiful Disaster
S11:E180 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Erica Messer - 8.0/10(13 votes)
#11 - Alchemy
S8:E200 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Sharon Lee Watson - 7.6/10(6 votes)
#12 - The Tall Man
S14:E50 CommentsView allDirector:Matthew Gray GublerWriter:Breen Frazier