The best episode directed by John McNaughton is "Maple Street", rated 7.7/10 from 3 user votes. It was "written by Maria Maggenti". "Maple Street" aired on 1/9/2003 and is rated 1.6 point(s) higher than their second highest rated, "Haeckel's Tale".
Annie Miller disappears on her way to school. The group looks into her disappearance, with their suspects ranging from the local mayor, to Annie's godfather, all the way to a young man working for the father of her best friend. Twenty-four hours after Annie's disappearance, her best friend Siobhan Arintero also vanishes, leaving only a collection of videos to help find the two girls.
Director: John McNaughton
Writer: Maria Maggenti
Based on Clive Barker's short story. While on his way to see his sick father, Ernest Haeckel takes shelter with an elderly man and his young wife but soon discovers their horrible secret...
Director: John McNaughton
Writer: Mick Garris