Brothers and Sisters backdrop
Brothers and Sisters S5E17 — Olivia's Choice
8.1
Brothers and Sisters•Season 5•Episode 17

Olivia's Choice

8.1/10 · 124 votesApr 10, 201145 min

Ranked #10 of 22 in Season 5•matches the season avg

Discussion

When Olivia's brother shows up and sets out to gain custody of her from Kevin and Scotty, the Walkers struggle amongst themselves to determine what's best for Olivia.

Written byStephen Tolkin
Previous episodeE16 · Home Is Where The Fort IsNext episodeE18 · Never Say Never
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons5

All12345

Season 5 Episodes22

The Homecoming stillE1 8.0

The Homecoming

Brief Encounter stillE2 7.8

Brief Encounter

Faking It stillE3 7.7

Faking It

A Righteous Kiss stillE4 8.2

A Righteous Kiss

Call Mom stillE5 8.1

Call Mom

An Ideal Husband stillE6 8.3

An Ideal Husband

Resolved stillE7 8.0

Resolved

The Rhapsody of the Flesh stillE8 7.6

The Rhapsody of the Flesh

Get A Room stillE9 8.1

Get A Room

Cold Turkey stillE10 7.8

Cold Turkey

Scandalized stillE11 7.8

Scandalized

Thanks For the Memories stillE12 8.0

Thanks For the Memories

Safe at Home stillE13 7.7

Safe at Home

One That Got Away stillE14 7.8

One That Got Away

Brody stillE15 8.3

Brody

Home Is Where The Fort Is stillE16 7.7

Home Is Where The Fort Is

Olivia's Choice stillE17 8.1Now viewing

Olivia's Choice

Never Say Never stillE18 8.1

Never Say Never

Wouldn’t It Be Nice stillE19 8.2

Wouldn’t It Be Nice

Father Unknown stillE20 8.7

Father Unknown

For Better Or For Worse stillE21 8.3

For Better Or For Worse

Walker Down the Aisle stillE22 9.0

Walker Down the Aisle

Cast9

Dave Annable

Dave Annable

Justin Walker

Sally Field

Sally Field

Nora Walker

Calista Flockhart

Calista Flockhart

Kitty Walker

Rachel Griffiths

Rachel Griffiths

Sarah Walker

Matthew Rhys

Matthew Rhys

Kevin Walker

Ron Rifkin

Ron Rifkin

Saul Holden

Luke Macfarlane

Luke Macfarlane

Scotty Wandell

Gilles Marini

Gilles Marini

Luc Laurent

Patricia Wettig

Patricia Wettig

Holly Harper

Crew2

Stephen Tolkin

Stephen Tolkin

Writer

Travis Braun

Travis Braun

Production Assistant

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"Olivia's Choice" is episode 17 of Brothers and Sisters season 5. It scored 8.1/10 from 124 votes, ranking #10 of 22 episodes this season (season average 8.1). Written by Stephen Tolkin, it aired on April 10, 2011.

Next: E18 · Never Say NeverBest of Season 5