Myldred was in love with KJ for four years when she discovered KJ was also secretly in a relationship with India; hungry for answers, both ladies join forces with Nev and Kamie to find out who they've really given their hearts to.

Guys slide into model Tracii's DMs all the time, but none are as special as Ace; after countless hours on the phone with her love, Tracii hopes Nev and Kamie can find the mystery man on the other end of the line.

After a year of online dating, Michael convinced Romeo to move to Atlanta to pursue their dream of being together. Now Romeo’s in Atlanta but Michael still won’t meet up! Nev and Kamie are on the case to help track Michael down!

Adam has fallen head over heels for online angel Mercy, but now she's asking for money and Adam is worried; with an engagement ring in hand, Nev and Kamie search to the ends of the Earth to help Adam find the love of his life.

Emma is in over her head after an online relationship with college football player EJ turns into a dangerous stalker who won't leave her alone! Will Nev and Kamie be able to help Emma find and stop EJ before he goes too far?

Gabby was heartbroken when she discovered her online love Kendrick was KILLED! But when Gabby's cousin suspects she's been mourning a fictional character, she calls in Nev & Kamie to uncover a truth that's stranger than fiction!

William was once a catfish, but now returns as a hopeful looking for love; Nev and Kamie ditch Zoom and hit the streets to help William find out if he has got a shot at romance or if he's about to get a taste of his own medicine.

Hayley met Britani on Instagram and fell fast in love, but Hayley’s sister thinks Britani is sus. Now, with Hayley planning a dangerous trip to meet Britani, her sister is worried and calls Nev and Kamie to find answers ASAP!

For six years, Pamela has spent thousands and has been kicked out of her home, all in pursuit of her sweet Fernando from Venezuela. But when Catfish comes calling, it seems that Fernando might be closer than anyone expected!

Onyx felt Lola was a divine gift sent from above when she slid into his DMs. But after months of failing to meet in person, Nev and Kamie help Onyx figure out whether Lola is really a heavenly blessing or a just a cruel curse.

Victoria calls on Catfish to help her meet the fine man that she’s been chatting with for eight years! But what Nev and Kamie uncover chills Victoria to the bone. Has someone she’s trusted been lying to her for all this time?

Nick struggled to meet other gay men until he met England; a weird business trip has Nick thinking that England's work might be more than meets the eye.

Helping Ivy with Dante, who writes love poems and talks marriage but never shows up in person.

Helping Keontae discover whether Tyler's sexual identity is the only thing he is hiding.

Kaycee, a single mom of two, couldn't resist Mike's charms when she met him online. But his odd disappearances concern Nev and Kamie, who help Kaycee uncover shocking secrets that make her question everything she ever knew about Mike.

Reese was always successful with women until he met Jesica, a gorgeous girl who was doing more than playing hard to get. When a shady set of phone numbers sparks Reese’s suspicions, he calls on Nev & Kamie to investigate.

Musician Flavour has been sweet talking mother of 3 Kimberly on Instagram, and she’s fallen in love. But Kimberly’s been scammed in the past, so when Flavour starts asking for gifts, her daughter calls Catfish for help!

While playing in an online virtual world, Charles and Nikki's avatars met and fell fast in love, but when Nev and Kamie uncover sketchy details on Nikki, Charles wonders whether his virtual dream girl will ever become a reality.

Rudy met Tyrell in a teen chat room over 17 years ago but Tyrell has never been able to meet her! Rudy now wants Nev and Kamie to help her find her elusive longtime lover in the hopes this could be the most epic love story ever!

John has fallen for Facebook beauty Megan, but despite living an hour away, she keeps making excuses not to meet. John's best friend thinks she's lying, but John is convinced that she could actually be the love of his life.

Mark was fast in love when he found his dream girl Taylor on an online game and soon the two became a couple! Nev and Kamie, less convinced of this virtual match, help Mark figure out if Taylor really is the girl of his dreams!

Angel met Sharon on a dating site and quickly formed a deep emotional connection over their shared trauma. Feeling Sharon is sus, Kamie and Nev help Angel expose whether Sharon and her tumultuous life are really fact or fiction!

Missy came into Malcolm's life after a period of loss and incarceration, and gave him much-needed joy, but her flaky behavior has him seeking answers from Nev and guest host Laura Perlongo.

After 20 years, Motherwolff, a devout satanist and witch, is now ready for her true love David.

Shay and Ceejay have been in a dramatic, years-long roller-coaster romance, but when Ceejay ghosts Shay, she asks Nev and guest host Tallulah Willis for help.