Season 1

• 

  6.9/10410 votes

  Almost Like a Prayer

  Season 1 Episode 1 - Aired 3/19/2025

  Reeling from the grief of a failed adoption, the Barnett family gets a second chance when they get a call about a little girl named Natalia.

  Director: Liz Garbus

  Writer: Katie Robbins

• 

  7.1/10282 votes

  Jump the Jitters Out

  Season 1 Episode 2 - Aired 3/19/2025

  Natalia starts school, and Kristine's suspicions about the adoption deepen. Michael receives unexpected news at work.

  Director: Stacie Passon

  Writer: Katie Robbins

• 

  7.2/10246 votes

  Ghosts Everywhere

  Season 1 Episode 3 - Aired 3/26/2025

  Kristine investigates Natalia's age. As she doubles down on her suspicions, Jacob's star rises and Michael's web of lies spins further.

  Director: Seith Mann

  Writer: Sarah Sutherland

• 

  7.4/10228 votes

  Right There in Black and White

  Season 1 Episode 4 - Aired 4/2/2025

  Michael and Kristine's marriage reaches a breaking point as their differing perspectives on Natalia threaten to tear them apart. When the stakes become dangerous, Kristine draws a line.

  Director: Eva Vives

  Writer: Eoghan O'Donnell

• 

  7.7/10240 votes

  Too Hurty Without It

  Season 1 Episode 5 - Aired 4/9/2025

  Left to her own devices, Natalia faces her new circumstances and how the world sees her.

  Director: Liz Garbus

  Writer: Katie Robbins

• 

  7.8/10227 votes

  Not Today Satan

  Season 1 Episode 6 - Aired 4/16/2025

  Natalia questions whether she can trust an unexpected set of allies. As questions about her past arise, painful memories are unearthed.

  Director: Hannah Fidell

  Writer: Jaquén Castellanos

• 

  7.6/10152 votes

  If You Tell a Story Well Enough

  Season 1 Episode 7 - Aired 4/23/2025

  Just as the Barnetts think they've distanced themselves from Natalia, Detective Drysdale takes up her case to challenge her re-aging.

  Director: Iain B. MacDonald

  Writer: Samantha Levenshus

• 

  7.8/10134 votes

  Blood on Her Hands

  Season 1 Episode 8 - Aired 4/30/2025

  With the world watching, Natalia and the Barnetts face off in the court of law and the court of public opinion.

  Director: Iain B. MacDonald

  Writer: Katie Robbins, Sarah Sutherland