Season 2 Episodes3
Cast1
Mikey Day
Self - Host
Discussion
0 comments
Join the conversation
Share your take and reply to other fans.
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.
6.2
Scaring up a Winner
6.2/10 · 6 votesOct 9, 202641 min
Ranked #2 of 2 in Season 2•−0.4 vs season avg
To win the grand prize, the finalists conjure cakes with eerie interactive elements. Guest judges: Kristen Schaal, Paul Scheer and Cedric Yarbrough
Seasons2
Episode Summary
"Scaring up a Winner" is episode 3 of Is It Cake? Halloween season 2. It scored 6.2/10 from 6 votes, ranking #2 of 2 episodes this season (season average 6.6). It aired on October 9, 2026.