When a young lawyer from Toronto decides to become an Imam, he decides to move west to the prairies to pursue his true calling. As the new spiritual leader arrives in his new home, the Muslim community butts heads with locals.

Thorne tricks Amaar into taking part in a charity boxing match and Amaar finds that if he tries to back out, he might lose face in the community.

Amaar and Reverend Thorne become lost during a camping trip in the woods. During their struggle to find the way home, the two discover they have more in common than either believed previously.

With an archbishop coming for a visit and looking to meet the Muslims in Mercy, Thorne tries to hide the fact that he has evicted the mosque.

The mosque has a new member and this leads to much discussion among the populace of Mercy.

Rayyan considers dating a local fireman and this proves to be unsettling for a few people.

An open house held in Mercy that is meant to bridge gaps between the Muslim and non-Muslim communities has unexpected consequences.

Rayaan and her mother have an argument over the swimming schedule at the local pool.

When Baber decides to put up a barrier to separate men and women at the mosque, a war of words along gender lines erupts.

Baber and Yasir decide to set up a Muslim cemetary but this does not go over well with some in the local community.

During preparations for New Year's Eve festivities, many people in Mercy reflect back on what they were doing five years earlier.

Amaar challenges Fred Tupper to a curling showdown though Amaar's knowledge of the sport is rather limited.

Sarah feels undervalued by Ann and agrees to work for Darnelly’s Mayor, Glenda Beckford, not realizing that Ann’s college ‘frenemy’ has ulterior motives for hiring her. Meanwhile, Amaar is so consumed with his plans for the new Mosque, he manages to forget Rayyan’s birthday. Baber and Thorne compete for clients at the mosque/church’s last rummage sale.

Amaar and Rayyan become co-hosts of a public access Islam themed show.

A Burka wearing newcomer stirs up a wide range of emotions in Mercy.

A local company's stock price rises dramatically and everybody in town wants to take advantage of the opportunity.

Baber starts to rethink his outlook on life when Amaar inadvertently gives him the " evil eye ".

Rayyan decides to add a few yuletide touches to cheer up Sarah, who is openly longing for the traditions of Christmas.

A childhood friend of Rayyan's visits Mercy and Rayyan finds herself infatuated.

Yasir's mother arrives for a visit and has plans that could prove disruptive for him and his family.

Sarah is jubilant when she wins the lottery until she remembers that, as a practicing Muslim, she isn't supposed to gamble.

Amaar has to deal with conflicting emotions when a former friend and now bitter rival comes to Mercy.

Amaar thinks Layla has a crush on him and tries to figure out a way of ending it quickly.

Sarah looks to replace the " Welcome to Mercy " sign with one written in multiple languages but this proves to be more difficult than she anticipates.

J.J. and Rayyan look for a chaperone for their budding relationship.