MysteryDramaCBC TelevisionCitytv

The Best Seasons of Murdoch Mysteries

Every season of Murdoch Mysteries ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best seasons of Murdoch Mysteries!

Top season
Season 3
8.1avg
Best episode
S11E7 The Accident
9.2620 votes
#1

Season 3

13 Episodes

First Aired: Feb 2010

8.1/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE1 · The Murdoch Identity 8.5
#2

Season 11

18 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2017

8.1/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE7 · The Accident 9.2
#3

Season 4

13 Episodes

First Aired: Feb 2011

8.0/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE6 · Dead End Street 8.9

Other Seasons

#4

Season 6

13 Episodes

First Aired: Jan 2013

8.0/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE4 · A Study in Sherlock 8.4
#5

Season 9

18 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2015

8.0/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE16 · Bl**dy H*ll 8.6
#6

Season 5

13 Episodes

First Aired: Feb 2012

8.0/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE13 · Twentieth Century Murdoch 8.6
#7

Season 8

18 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2014

7.9/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE7 · What Lies Buried 8.6
#8

Season 2

13 Episodes

First Aired: Feb 2009

7.9/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE4 · Houdini Whodunit 8.2
#9

Season 7

18 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2013

7.9/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE4 · Return of Sherlock Holmes 8.3
#10

Season 20

6 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2026

7.9/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE5 · Missing Persons 8.9
#11

Season 10

18 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2016

7.8/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE18 · Hell to Pay 8.4
#12

Season 12

18 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2018

7.8/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE18 · Darkness Before the Dawn (2) 8.5
#13

Season 16

24 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2022

7.7/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE9 · Honeymoon in Hampshire 8.1
#14

Season 19

21 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2025

7.7/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE5 · The Borden Ultimatum 8.4
#15

Season 1

13 Episodes

First Aired: Jan 2008

7.6/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE13 · Annoying Red Planet 8.0
#16

Season 13

18 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2019

7.6/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE13 · Kill Thy Neighbour 8.2
#17

Season 15

24 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2021

7.5/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE11 · The Night Before Christmas 8.4
#18

Season 17

24 Episodes

First Aired: Oct 2023

7.5/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE10 · Mrs. Crabtree's Neighborhood 8.1
#19

Season 18

22 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2024

7.5/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE2 · Only Murdoch in the Building 7.8
#20

Season 14

11 Episodes

First Aired: Jan 2021

7.4/ 10
Average Rating
Best episodeE11 · Everything Is Broken (2) 8.1

Keep going

If you like Murdoch Mysteries