Cole lands in San Francisco for his straight best friend's engagement party. But when Cole secretly plans to use the trip as an excuse to move to the City, he discovers his best friend, Daren, has a secret of his own, too.

Daren and Rebecca have a heated discussion about Cole, and Cole discovers that his old sketchbook has mysterious powers, which leads Cole and Daren to run into Cole's former flame, Max, and Daren makes a major decision.

Cole realizes his power might actually be real and shares his discovery with Charlie. When he goes out to explore how it works, Daren realizes that he may have bigger issues to handle.

Cole and Daren go to Max's party, where Cole wants to spend time with Max, but finds a rival for Max's attention. Meanwhile, Daren makes a friend of his own and opens up about his uncertainties.

As Daren and Rebecca prepare for the engagement party in the evening, Cole starts to rekindle his relationship with Max. However, after receiving some bad news himself, Cole tells Rebecca about Daren's doubts.

Cole tries to use the sketchbook to fix the mess he's made. But when Rebecca kicks Daren and Cole out, Max saves the day and welcomes them into his apartment, where Cole realizes it may take more than his sketchbook to rectify things with Daren.