After being scared by a pirate's hat, Tubb wishes himself into becoming a pirate captain. However, he and his crew are blasted by cannonballs while being on an island.

After bumping her nose, Amelia becomes a princess, with her servants, Tubb and Finbar, worrying about her and not letting her out of her room.

Finbar does not want to be a rescuer in the Sponge Rescues, so he wants to be rescued instead.

When the Rubbadubbers give each other Christmas gifts, Finbar wishes that he has all the presents on Finbar Day.

Finbar is telling the other Rubbadubbers a ghost story, but his ghost noises are too funny to be scary! Wishing he could meet some real ghosts, Finbar is transported to a ghostly school. His students frighten Finbar with their terrifying variety of scares and Finbar quickly sees that it's better to be funny than scary.

After Sploshy's wish on a shooting star does not come true, she wants her own genie to give her wishes.

After not winning the bathroom games, Reg wishes himself into Sports World to find out his real strengths.

Tubb wants to build a house his way instead of following directions.

When Terence sees Finbar dress up like a monster in the bathroom, he wishes that everyone believed him.

Reg wants to read in peace, so he is transported to a library.

Tubb wants to grow hair, and styles it for a competition.

Reg does not want to take a break from keeping watch, so he gets transported to his own lighthouse.

Tubb wants more rooms after trying and failing to read a letter in peace.

Terence wants to be first with the news, so he becomes a 1400s explorer delivering news to a village.

Amelia wants to make pictures like her friends, but she cannot hold a paintbrush right.

Finbar keeps losing a word game, so he wants to know all the words.