Joanna attempts to spice up her love life by trying out a dating app while Peter tries to meet girls IRL. Getting mixed results, they decide to swipe for each other and set up blind dates.

At her ex's wedding, Joanna has an epiphany about Peter, while he takes full advantage of his status as "the single guy at a wedding."

Peter and Joanna go on their first date together. Lisa is visiting Mark's place to approve him for Chloe.

Peter and Joanna made a pact to marry if they were still single by 30. After losing touch, Joanna re-enters Peter's life on his birthday. Confronted Unsettled by the reality of their lives, they reinstate the pact.

Peter and Joanna revisit their college years when they see Grace's first DJ set at a frat party. Mark and Chloe take their mind games to the next level.

Chloe is moving in with Mark. Peter is moving on from Joanna.

Mark proposes Chloe and she accepts. Peter is going to San Francisco for his job interview, while Joanna has taken additional responsibility as a substitute choir teacher at her school.

Joanna reconnects with an ex as Peter tries to impress Sarah's friends. Mark and Chloe attempt to take their relationship to the next level, by going on an "official" date.