Still a Mystery backdrop
Still a Mystery poster
Documentary
Crime
Reality

The Best Episodes of Still a Mystery

Every episode of Still a Mystery ranked from best to worst. Let's dive into the Best Episodes of Still a Mystery!

The Best Episodes of Still a Mystery

Each episode re-examines a single crime case where unanswered questions still remain. Through original interviews those involved, the evidence is dissected and new theories are...

Filter By Season6

  1. 7.2/10(16 votes)

    #1 - Killers Among Us?

    S2:E7

    A respected police officer heads home after a late shift, and a young man who has just moved into his own place relaxes after watching football. How do these routine evenings turn deadly? Were their killings cold-blooded assassinations?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  2. 7.2/10(11 votes)

    #2 - Small Town Secrets

    S3:E11

    A man's trip ends badly. A missing mom's search party sparks suspicion.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  3. 7.1/10(14 votes)

    #3 - Her Last Night Out

    S2:E9

    No description available

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  4. 7.0/10(28 votes)

    #4 - Down The Hill

    S1:E2

    Thirteen-year-old Abby Williams and 14-year-old Libby German disappear while hiking on a popular trail; 13-year-old Dylan Redwine vanishes over Thanksgiving break while visiting his father in Vallecito, Colo.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  5. 7.0/10(15 votes)

    #5 - Why Did She Leave?

    S2:E12

    She is an innocent bride-to-be; he's a six-year-old schoolboy. Both are on the road, away from home, when they disappear. When her car and body are found, will the clues lead to her murderer? And will his family ever solve the mystery of his vanishing?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  6. 7.0/10(10 votes)

    #6 - Indiana Unsolved

    S5:E3

    A college student sends his sister a mysterious text about leaving the country. Later, his body turns up in a lake, weighed down by a backpack full of rocks. A young woman vanishes after trying to make a call from a payphone.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 WORST Episodes of Still a Mystery

    READ
  8. 6.9/10(26 votes)

    #7 - The Dangerous Houses

    S1:E1

    Eighteen-year-old Brookelyn Farthing disappears in 2013 after attending a party in Berea, Ky.; 24-year-old realtor Lindsay Buziak is found brutally killed after showing new clients a million-dollar home.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  9. 6.9/10(19 votes)

    #8 - The Gone Girls

    S1:E5

    In Mobile, Ala., young mother Danniella Vian, 25, disappears into thin air; 19-year-old Holly Moore's suspicious death still raises questions four years after her body is found hanging in her closet

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  10. 6.8/10(17 votes)

    #9 - Guns and Secrets

    S2:E15

    One young woman is found with a shotgun wound to her head shortly after moving in with her new boyfriend. Then, a couple planning their wedding are gunned down in their own backyard. Will secrets from the past explain these unimaginable deaths?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  11. 6.8/10(11 votes)

    #10 - Charmed by a Killer

    S3:E12

    One mom is missing and another spurs a manhunt for her daughter's killer.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  12. 6.8/10(12 votes)

    #11 - Suspects at Large

    S3:E13

    In an ironic twist, a woman vanishes while looking for her missing friend.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  13. 6.8/10(11 votes)

    #12 - Southern Secrets

    S4:E1

    When two women die suddenly under mysterious circumstances, authorities initially suspect suicide. But both of their families believe it was murder, and are trying to figure out who is responsible.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  14. 6.7/10(11 votes)

    #13 - Somebody Knows Something

    S3:E10

    A severed foot is an ominous clue in the case of a missing mother of five.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  15. 6.6/10(17 votes)

    #14 - She Gave No Warning

    S2:E4

    When two young women vanish without a trace, investigators are haunted by the things they leave behind - a car with the keys still in the ignition, a pair of shoes, and a coat. They disappear with no warning. Where have they gone?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  16. 6.6/10(14 votes)

    #15 - Young Love Gone Wrong

    S2:E5

    They are head over heels in love with their whole lives ahead still ahead of them, but then they die suddenly under suspicious circumstances. Could the strange text messages that come from their own phones hold the clues that investigators need?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  17. 6.6/10(14 votes)

    #16 - The Hidden Bodies

    S2:E11

    After struggles in their youth, they are setting out on new paths with new hope but then the unthinkable happens. Their horrific murders are chilling. Who would kill them in such a violent way? Did they have any idea how much danger they were in?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  18. 6.6/10(13 votes)

    #17 - Death and Silence

    S2:E16

    The body of a young musician turns up in an alley. Police learn she's been spending time with an older man. Did he play a part in her murder? And when a construction worker disappears on the job, his coworkers' accounts don't add up. What are they hiding?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  19. 6.6/10(7 votes)

    #18 - Where The Clues Lead

    S4:E6

    He seems like a great partner. But when Susan Osborne and her 14-year-old son Evan disappear, it turns out "Mr. Right" has a secret. Then, when a young man is shot in a street confrontation, all clues point to one man. Could this case be that simple?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  20. 6.5/10(22 votes)

    #19 - The Midnight Murders

    S1:E3

    Florida insurance agent Carla Stefaniak vanishes in Costa Rica; 19-year-old college student Pravin Varughese disappears after a party in 2014.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  21. 6.5/10(15 votes)

    #20 - Brides and Murder

    S2:E3

    Two young brides-to-be are just beginning to plan their weddings when their dreams are tragically cut short. Can desperate calls made to 911 reveal the truth about their shocking deaths?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  22. 6.5/10(14 votes)

    #21 - Innocence Interrupted

    S2:E8

    The murders of a teenage boy who never returns home from school and a teenage girl who is ambushed as she sits in a car with friends devastate their communities. It is every parent's worst nightmare - who would kill two innocent teenagers?

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  23. 6.5/10(14 votes)

    #22 - Targeted in the Night

    S3:E3

    A girl vanishes on her way home, and an entrepreneur dies after a fight.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  24. 6.5/10(11 votes)

    #23 - Best Lives Cut Short

    S3:E7

    A beer entrepreneur is gunned down, and two friends die while on vacation.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  25. 6.5/10(11 votes)

    #24 - She Turns Up Dead

    S4:E2

    A mother of two and a young woman planning a career in science both die under mysterious circumstances, and two families embark on quests for justice.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A
  26. 6.4/10(25 votes)

    #25 - Secrets in the Cars

    S1:E4

    After a night out with friends, Jaleayah Davis, 20, is found dead; Kelsie Schelling, 21, drives two hours to show her boyfriend a sonogram of their baby, but never makes it home.

    0 Comments
    View all
    Director:N/A
    Writer:N/A

Best Episodes Summary

"Killers Among Us?" is the best rated episode of "Still a Mystery". It scored 7.2/10 based on 16 votes. Directed by N/A and written by N/A, it aired on 7/7/2020. This episode scored 0.0 points higher than the second highest rated, "Small Town Secrets".