The town is in shock when a heart is cut from a corpse at the funeral home. Meanwhile, the town believes a recluse taints halloween treats.

While Tony suffers from loss of sleep after becoming a father again, he puzzles over the case of a rapist who has diplomatic immunity.

David is the only witness to a shooting involving his best friend and a bullying classmate. Tony pursues the case unaware of David's knowledge of the shooting. The victim’s father, skeptical of police justice, plans to mete out his own.

Rachel becomes the target of a killer when she witnesses a murder whilst grocery shopping.

A rapist is targeting blind female college students. Rachel makes an investment in art.

Tony escapes from the kidnappers with the help of the porn producer and then they pursue a film entrpreneur.

An old friend of Tony's is having marital trouble—which could be causing deadly incidents.

Tony hunts for a kidnapped infant who is seriously ill.

David's behavior and school works deteriorates. A group of young men from a prep school commit a burglary and one of them suspiciously disappears.

Following on from the previous episode; Nick Collete seeks revenge and Tony continues his crusade to bring him to justice.

When budget cuts hit the Eastbridge PD, the majority of officers call in sick. This leaves the remaining officers to tackle a series of "push-in" robberies. Rachel goes to a her school reunion without Tony, but instead of going by herself she accepts the offer to attend with an old school beau.

Things are not going well for Tony: he's carjacked of his gift of a new car for Rachel, a patient from psychiatric hospital escapes, things are further complicated because the escapee is a master of disguise. Tony also suffers with kidney stones, which means that he has to go to hospital leaving Cyd in charge.

While Stan is having problems protecting Carmela from a curse, Tony thinks that a video dating service's client is a homicidal thief.

The son of Nick Collette arrives in Eastbridge, which causes more trouble for Tony and a local businessman.

A new reality police show comes to town. Meanwhile, a former movie star is implicated in her ex lover's murder.

The daughter of one of Tony's friends is missing, so he and Paulie pose as porn film investors to find out the truth.

Rachel redecorates. One of Tony's friends, who harbors a secret, is a target from an escaped convict.

A notorious mob boss retires to Eastbridge and, in turn, the crime rate rises.

A man takes his ex-wife hostage. Things are further complicated by the involvement of one Tony's officers. The psychic who found the ring Tony was giving to Rachel in a previous episode returns, but this time with a warning about Tony's planned anniversary dinner but, is there an ulterior motive?

Tony is astonished to discover a wealthy socialite is the proprietor of a prostitution ring. The socialite is murdered, but not before Tony's name is discovered in her rolodex of clients.

Tony receives mysterious telephone calls from someone who can help solve a drug dealer’s murder. Rachel gets a good job offer that, ultimately, could mean a move to Buffalo.

Rachel goes into labor, Tony is kept away due to a friends crisis.