During her sister's bachelorette party, Bella visits a local psychic to get her fortune told. Surprisingly for Bella, the psychic tells her that she has already dated her future husband, and that if she doesn't marry him in the next year, she'll remain single forever. Following signs that come her way, Bella tracks down one of her exes, who has become a rock musician since their break-up.

Bella reunites with her ex, Jake, a former couch potato who plans strenuous activities for their dates to prove he isn't a slacker anymore; Cyrus invents a drinking game for the gang.

When her apartment is robbed, Bella is reunited with her ex-boyfriend, Ronny, a former bad boy-turned cop.

Bella reconnects with a free-spirited surfer she broke up with years earlier because she thought he would never grow up.