Toby gathers information from a traumatized rape victim whose attacker Marks failed to convict in the past. During his probe, Toby discovers Marks may have a deeper connection to the case.

Becker's involvement in a criminal conspiracy sparks an investigation by Toby, Michelle and Dev.

With Michelle's career on the line, Toby and the IIB must prove she was set up after a bad tip led to the shooting of a suspect.

Toby and the IIB race to track the source of a deadly virus before the outbreak claims any more lives.

While the team investigates a botched magic stunt that killed an investment guru, Becker’s scrutiny of Toby threatens to expose his secret.

Toby uses his telepathy as surveillance when Michelle goes undercover to bust a violent art theft ring.

When Magnus Elphrenson escapes prison again, Toby must help Michelle recapture him before the criminal mastermind seeks vengeance on his nemesis.

Toby and Michelle investigate a series of violent home invasions, which are being interrupted by a vigilante citizen dressed as a superhero.

Visions of a missing girl prompt Toby to pursue a homeless man, who he thinks has information on her location. Soon, Toby begins to suspect that the man may also have psychic abilities.

Toby looks for answers about his past and his mother by sifting through the jumbled thoughts of an Alzheimer's patient.

While investigating the murder of a billionaire playboy, Toby's curiosities about his family arise.

Toby starts doubting his abilities after Michelle questions the veracity of his insights during their investigation into a wealthy philanthropist's murder.

A mayoral candidate is questioned for murder after Becker becomes interested in Toby's gift.

Despite his decision to stop using his telepathic abilities, Toby is forced to use them when he finds himself hostage in the middle of a bank heist. It will take all of Toby's skills, both as a paramedic and a mind reader, to keep him and his fellow hostages alive.

Toby and Michelle investigate the death of a pharmaceutical executive who released a drug with killer results.

Toby and Dev investigate a serial killer who leaves live snakes with his victims, echoing the calling card of a past culprit who Michelle had previously put behind bars. Meanwhile, Michelle is trying to enjoy her maternity leave with her new baby girl and husband Adam but when her credibility is doubted with the suggestion that she may have arrested the wrong suspect, she must return to the IIB in order to save her professional reputation.

Toby faces a mentally unstable suspect in the murder investigation of a psychiatrist.

The team must find a treasure in order to solve the murder of a man responsible for a coin heist.

The team investigates the murder of a cooking show contestant, poisoned on live television.

After being drugged, Toby is implicated in an armed kidnapping.

Toby goes under cover when he believes an innocent man is taking the fall for a murder.

Working his first official investigation, Toby must contend with Alvin Klein's skepticism and personal agenda in solving a decade-old murder.

After a member of a superstar performer’s crew is electrocuted by a microphone, Toby finds himself amidst the entourage of Jade, one of pop music’s most popular and innovative performers.

Toby and the IIB team investigate the abduction of a ballerina after Tia tips them to corruption at a dance company.

Toby and Michelle investigate the link between a cult and the disappearance of three young women.