Just as they are teaching Lisa to canter, the Saddle Club is caught in a sudden storm. This leaves Stevie and Carole stranded on a cliffside and Lisa to overcome her fear of cantering and ride for help.

Phil and his Pony Club come to Pine Hollow to participate in a mystery weekend to raise funds. However, they soon discover there is a real thief in their midst and the Saddle Club sets out to catch the culprit once and for all.

The girls have to teach teenage heart-throb Skye Ransom how to ride to save his movie career.

When Lisa's mother decides to enroll Lisa in a private boarding school, Carole and Stevie do everything they can to stop Lisa from attending it.

With help from her father, Carole comes to terms with her mother's death and Cobalt's and is soon thrilled to learn that Delilah is pregnant with Cobalt's foal.

Stevie and Carole naturally blame Veronica when Lisa's school horse, Prancer, starts to act sluggish and unresponsive. However, Phil thinks he knows the true reason.

The Saddle Club girls think that Deborah has asked Max to sell Pine Hollow Stables. They succeed in breaking up the couple, only to realize that Max's happiness is more important to them than any stable.

Carole feels like The Saddle Club is falling apart: Stevie's too busy with her old friend, Tina, and Lisa's obsessed with beating out Veronica for the lead in the school play. The birth of Delilah's foal brings the Saddle Club together again

When Veronica appears to be neglecting her new horse, Garnet, in the same way she did with Cobalt, the Saddle Club girls enlist Phil's help to switch horses on Veronica and teach her a lesson.

During a western riding clinic at Pine Hollow, Stevie rescues an abandoned mare and names her Belle. Deborah writes an article about Stevie and Belle and their photo appears in the paper.

Belle's rightful owner, Chelsea, sees the picture of Stevie and Belle in the newspaper and travels to Pine Hollow to take back her horse. When Belle runs away from Chelsea and will only respond to Stevie, Chelsea decides that Belle's place is with Stevie at Pine Hollow.

Carole's role as best junior rider at Pine Hollow is threatened by the arrival of a talented, new rider, Andrea Barry.

Determined to break up the Saddle Club once and for all, Veronica makes a bet with Carole Carole can't go a day without running to Stevie and Lisa with information. Carole counters that Veronica couldn't manage even one day of doing her own barn chores. The loser must leave Pine Hollow.

Lisa and Veronica are forced to work together on the annual Pine Hollow costume party. Lisa gets even with Stevie for her practical jokes by staging an eerie prank of her own.

When Carole and Stevie's efforts awaken comatose Lisa, Pine Hollow is thrown into a frenzy to get Max and Deborah's wedding back on track. Also, Stevie and Phil finally admit they like each other.

A valuable horse named Hugo is transported from France arrives at Pine Hollow but escapes into danger. A thief seems to be operating in the stables and Veronica is blaming Scooter.

The valuable French horse is not everything it appears to be and the Saddle Club must find the real one quickly.

Dorothe Doutey, the French Junior Champion arrives at Pine Hollow and rumours begin to fly.

The Saddle Club coaxes Dorothee into riding Hugo again by getting Veronica to buy him. Veronica agrees to buy him, if she can sing with the Saddle Club at their first gig.

The Equine infection endangering the horses could mean the end of Pine Hollow and when Comanche gets sick, The Saddle Club try to do their best to try and save the horse.

When Veronica's horse, Garnet, is kidnapped, The Saddle Club sets out to solve the mystery. Meanwhile, Murray is driving Carole mad, both at home and at Pine Hollow. When Carole finds out that Murray might be involved in Garnet's kidnapping, she sets out to find out the real truth. Dorothée is invited by the French Olympic Panel to trial for selection for the Olympic Training Squad, but if she passes, it means leaving Pine Hollow and Red.

Both Dorothée and Max are faced with important decisions. The stables are divided about whether Dorothée should pursue her love with Red or her career as a show jumper. But in the end, the decision might lie with Dorothée's horse, Hugo.

When Pepper gets old, The Saddle Club is faced with the difficult task of finding a way for an old man and an old horse to enjoy a useful old age. Max's cousin, Drew takes over the stables while Max is away.

Peeved that Lisa won the captaincy of the Navigation Riding Team to take on Cross County, Veronica sets out to prove Phil is poisoning their horses so his club will have the advantage. When Lisa and Veronica find the cause of their horses' illness, it is a race to prevent the town's drinking water from being affected by poison. Stevie tries for her C-level Equestrian Certificate.

Stevie's judgment is clouded by her attempts to camouflage a pimple, and then she doesn't wear a helmet when riding out in the field on Belle. She then falls off and gets a bump on her head. Meanwhile, Veronica arranges to have a potential Olympic champion take her place so Kristi's team will win the prize of having their photograph in a prominent equestrian magazine. During the competition, Lisa and Carole find out why Stevie has been acting weird in the saddle and when waiting to ride in the competition.