Pastors and parents, Ben and Jewel Tankard, work at raising their blended family under one roof. Ben becomes protective when a young man courts his youngest daughter, Cyrene, as his prom date. Brooklyn longs for her family’s support when her marathon coincides with Cyrene’s prom. Britney and Brooklyn go on a double date where their checkered pasts are revealed.

Cyrene puts her health in jeopardy by eating the wrong thing; Brooklyn asks Marcus to give her honest feedback on her vocal skills; Marcus and Tish must learn how to compromise as parents when it comes to raising their son, Micah.