High school teacher Tara Grinstead is missing for over a decade when podcaster Payne Lindsey begins to investigate helping lead to the arrest of two former students. When they plead not guilty, Payne’s team heads back to Georgia to crack the case.

News anchor Jodi Huisentruit vanishes before her morning newscast in Iowa. For the next 24 years, her family and friends are tormented with theories of her demise. Payne and the team dive into the cold case to find out the truth about Jodi.

The mysterious disappearance of Korrina Malinoski, and daughter Annette, from their South Carolina home, has continued to baffle family and police for the past 30 years. Payne and team work to connect the clues and reunite a family in the process.

29-year-old Krystal Reisinger went to Colorado on a spiritual journey in 2016 and vanished. Police and family believe foul play is involved, but there are few clues. Payne explored this case on his podcast, but now they hope to solve it.

17-year-old Molly Miller and 21-year-old Colt Haynes vanish after a high-speed chase with police. When Payne learns that the suspect is related to someone in law enforcement that was charged with corruption, the team heads to Oklahoma to unravel the mystery.

In 2006 business executive Jennifer Keese, 27, goes missing from Orlando, FL. Payne Lindsey and his team work with her family in search of answers.