The best episode written by Cal Coons is "A Study in Sherlock", rated 7.8/10 from 6 user votes. It was "directed by Don McCutcheon". "A Study in Sherlock" aired on 1/28/2013 and is rated 0.7 point(s) higher than their second highest rated, "Til Death Do Us Part".
Two bank safe deposit boxes that were being transferred are taken by thieves and the crime is investigated by Detective Murdoch. The getaway driver for the thieves is killed. While on scene someone claiming to be Sherlock Holmes shows up and provides some helpful information. Dr. Ogden figures out that he is actually David Kingsley who at one time was treated for mental illness. "Sherlock Holmes" appears to have the qualities of the fictional character of the same name such as the ability to "read" an individual or a crime scene.
Director: Don McCutcheon
Writer: Cal Coons
When it is revealed that a man murdered on his wedding day was homosexual, Murdoch finds himself fighting his own beliefs.
Director: Don McBrearty
Writer: Cal Coons