Episode Hive Logo

The Best Episodes Written By Carter Bays

Every TV Episode Written by Carter Bays Ranked from Best to Worst by Thousands of Voters

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Fan Favorite
    undefined Season 1 Episode 10 - The Pineapple Incident
    8.5/10(45 votes)

    #1 - The Pineapple Incident

    S1:E10

    After being forced into knocking back 5 shots, so he will stop thinking, Ted goes on a partying rampage. The next morning he wakes up with a woman in his bed, but he does not know who it is. So he turns to his friends to try and piece the night together and work out who the woman is in his bed.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. undefined Season 5 Episode 8 - The Playbook
    8.5/10(34 votes)

    #2 - The Playbook

    S5:E8

    After his relationship with Robin ends, Barney dusts off his "playbook" to help him back into the dating scene

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. undefined Season 6 Episode 10 - Blitzgiving
    8.4/10(32 votes)

    #3 - Blitzgiving

    S6:E10

    When Ted leaves the bar early to prepare a Thanksgiving feast for his friends, the gang winds up partying all night with The Blitz, an old friend from college who has bad luck. As a result Ted is forced to spend Thanksgiving with Zoey.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. undefined Season 2 Episode 22 - Something Blue
    8.3/10(31 votes)

    #4 - Something Blue

    S2:E22

    It's still Marshall and Lily's big wedding day but now we're at the reception. Robin tries to tell a story but keeps getting interrupted. Barney tries his hardest to figure out Ted and Robin's secret.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. undefined Season 3 Episode 13 - Ten Sessions
    8.2/10(33 votes)

    #5 - Ten Sessions

    S3:E13

    Ted pursues a woman named Stella, but only gets attention from her receptionist Abby.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. undefined Season 5 Episode 12 - Girls vs. Suits
    8.2/10(31 votes)

    #6 - Girls vs. Suits

    S5:E12

    When Barney debates giving up wearing suits in order to land a hot bartender, his conflicted feelings lead to an amazingly awesome musical number. Meanwhile, Ted gets one step closer to meeting the future mother of his kids.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  7. undefined Season 1 Episode 22 - Come On
    8.2/10(43 votes)

    #7 - Come On

    S1:E22

    Ted tries to keep Robin from going on a camping trip so that she can spend time with him. Barney enlists the help of an old flame to perform a rain dance. At the same time Marshall finds out about Lily's interview for the fellowship in San Francisco.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. undefined Season 4 Episode 1 - Do I Know You?
    8.1/10(31 votes)

    #8 - Do I Know You?

    S4:E1

    Ted and Stella get engaged, but Ted soon learns that he doesn't know anything about her. Meanwhile, Barney confesses to Lily that he's in love with Robin.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  9. undefined Season 5 Episode 24 - Doppelgangers
    8.1/10(30 votes)

    #9 - Doppelgangers

    S5:E24

    Marshall and Lily make a secret pact to start trying to have a baby if they ever finally see Barney's doppelganger. Meanwhile, Robin finally gets an offer for her dream job.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  10. undefined Season 3 Episode 11 - The Platinum Rule
    8.0/10(34 votes)

    #10 - The Platinum Rule

    S3:E11

    Ted's upcoming date with his doctor leads the gang to give him their own examples of why dating someone you already see regularly is a bad idea.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  11. undefined Season 3 Episode 20 - Miracles
    8.0/10(31 votes)

    #11 - Miracles

    S3:E20

    Ted is in a car accident that prompts Marshall to talk about miracles. Everyone flashbacks to prior moments in their lives.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  12. undefined Season 4 Episode 2 - The Best Burger in New York
    8.0/10(28 votes)

    #12 - The Best Burger in New York

    S4:E2

    Marshall claims that he had the best hamburger in the world during his first week in New York City, but he forgot where the burger joint is located. The gang then hits the streets of Manhattan to help him find it.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  13. undefined Season 5 Episode 1 - Definitions
    8.0/10(31 votes)

    #13 - Definitions

    S5:E1

    After sharing a kiss at the beginning of the summer, Robin and Barney are unsure how to handle their mutual attraction. After some consideration they tell the gang they have decided to remain just friends, but secretly continue seeing each other. They are able to get away with their secret romance for a couple months, but are discovered when Ted, Marshall and Lily walk in on them together. They explain to the gang that they are happy with their casual relationship, and didn’t want to complicate it by defining it. This is unacceptable to Lily, who pressures them to label their situation, and ultimately locks them in Robin’s room to force them to address it. Meanwhile, Ted is anxious about his first days as a professor at Columbia, which is made worse when he shows up at the wrong class and starts his lecture.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  14. undefined Season 1 Episode 21 - Milk
    7.9/10(42 votes)

    #14 - Milk

    S1:E21

    When a matchmaking company calls Ted claiming they have found his soul mate, he is forced to postpone his date when Lily asks for his help.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  15. undefined Season 1 Episode 18 - Nothing Good Happens After 2 A.M.
    7.9/10(42 votes)

    #15 - Nothing Good Happens After 2 A.M.

    S1:E18

    Robin, who is very lonely, asks Ted to come over to her apartment after 2 A.M., but he isn't sure if he wants to go as he has a phone call on the way over with his friends, and with Victoria on his mind

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  16. undefined Season 2 Episode 14 - Monday Night Football
    7.9/10(36 votes)

    #16 - Monday Night Football

    S2:E14

    When a funeral conflicts with the Super Bowl, the gang vows to avoid hearing the score and watch it together on Monday. This proves difficult, as Marshall is threatened with the score by a boy in Lily's class, while doing the news puts Robin in danger of finding out who won.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  17. undefined Season 4 Episode 24 - The Leap
    7.9/10(30 votes)

    #17 - The Leap

    S4:E24

    Ted is trying to keep his architecture firm afloat by doing an all-nighter, but Marshall tries to lure him to the roof for a surprise 31st birthday party, on the fourth season finale.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  18. undefined Season 5 Episode 3 - Robin 101
    7.9/10(29 votes)

    #18 - Robin 101

    S5:E3

    When Robin fears that Barney is cheating on her, she soon discovers that he is spending his evenings with Ted learning everything there is to know on how to date her.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  19. undefined Season 7 Episode 24 - The Magician's Code (2)
    7.9/10(29 votes)

    #19 - The Magician's Code (2)

    S7:E24

    Ted is conflicted when Victoria approaches him on her wedding day and asks him to elope. Meanwhile, Barney and Quinn are arrested by airport security while on the way to Hawaii when Barney refuses to open a box they are travelling with.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  20. undefined Season 9 Episode 20 - Daisy
    7.9/10(36 votes)

    #20 - Daisy

    S9:E20

    Marshall asks Barney and Ted for help figuring out where Lily went in the middle of the night during their argument.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  21. undefined Season 9 Episode 22 - The End of the Aisle
    7.9/10(33 votes)

    #21 - The End of the Aisle

    S9:E22

    With only a half an hour left before the wedding, Robin and Barney panic; Lily and Marshall rewrite their wedding vows.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  22. undefined Season 3 Episode 1 - Wait For It
    7.8/10(32 votes)

    #22 - Wait For It

    S3:E1

    Robin shows up with a date and this motivates Ted to 'get back out there'. We also learn something major about 'the Mother'.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  23. undefined Season 4 Episode 15 - The Stinsons
    7.8/10(31 votes)

    #23 - The Stinsons

    S4:E15

    The gang thinks that Barney must have a secret girlfriend after noticing his bizarre behavior.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  24. undefined Season 6 Episode 8 - Natural History
    7.8/10(29 votes)

    #24 - Natural History

    S6:E8

    When the gang goes to a black tie event at the Natural History Museum, Ted gets introduced to Zoey's husband, The Captain.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  25. undefined Season 6 Episode 14 - Last Words
    7.8/10(30 votes)

    #25 - Last Words

    S6:E14

    While on a trip to Minnesota, Ted and Barney try anything to make Marshall laugh. Marshall runs into an old nemesis from high school.

    Director:N/A
    Writer:Carter Bays

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Carter Bays Ratings Summary

"The Pineapple Incident" is the best rated episode written by Carter Bays. It scored 8.511/10 based on 45 votes. It was directed by N/A. It aired on 11/28/2005 and is rated 0.0 points higher than their second-best episode, "The Playbook".