The best episode written by Nikki Schiefelbein is "Between Raising Hell and Amazing Grace", rated 8/10 from 2 user votes. It was "directed by Bethany Joy Lenz". "Between Raising Hell and Amazing Grace" aired on 11/16/2010 and is rated 1.0 point(s) higher than their second highest rated, "I Didn't Ask and She Didn't Say".
The gang gathers at Nathan and Haley’s to spend Thanksgiving with friends and family.
Director: Bethany Joy Lenz
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
Colt gets possessive when Heather starts dating a teacher. Abby gives Beau relationship advice. Maggie has a business proposition for Rooster
Director: David Trainer
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
Tension arises backstage at Peyton's USO show as Lucas deals with Peyton and Julian's past. While Haley tries to find a way to ease her stage fright, Nathan grapples with a decision that could forever change his career. Meanwhile, Brooke receives a call that could end her relationship with Sam and Millicent confronts Mouth over Gigi.
Director: Janice Cooke
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
Riley discovers the "client list" has been stolen and she must find out who took it before her secret life is exposed. Meanwhile, Evan's investigation into Carlyle reveals that Nikki used to be his employee, putting Evan one step closer to Riley's hidden life. Dale and Lacey get news that could accelerate their plans to have a family of their own. Derek asks Selena to make a commitment in their relationship, but Selena isn't sure she's ready.
Director: Jennifer Love Hewitt
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
Brooke and Julian try to find a balance between their personal lives and work as the movie shoot begins. Nathan and Haley receive a surprise visit, and Clay supports Quinn as she faces some unexpected news., Alex sets her sights on Alexander, and Millicent finds herself struggling with temptation.
Director: Jessica Landaw
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
As Heather's medical bills roll in, Colt realizes how expensive it is having a baby. A surprise visitor at the bar sweeps Maggie off her feet.
Director: David Trainer
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein
As Riley struggles with her marriage and recent decisions at work, she and Lacey decide to attend church with Georgia and Harold. Also, Harold plans a romantic gesture for Georgia. Kyle prepares to testify against his former employer and gets guidance from his lawyer, Graham. Meanwhile Selena warns Derek about his overzealous client Lisa, but reveals more about herself in the process than she intended. Evan takes his first real step moving on from Riley when he and Shelby have their first date.
Director: Debbie Allen
Writer: Nikki Schiefelbein