All's Fair S1E2 — When We Were Young

5.1

All's Fair•Season 1•Episode 2

When We Were Young

5.1/10 · 845 votesNov 4, 202543 min

Ranked #8 of 9 in Season 1•−0.7 vs season avg

A legendary lawyer comes out of retirement. Liberty weighs a pivotal decision.

Directed byAnthony Hemingway

Written byRyan Murphy, Jamie Pachino

Previous episodeE1 · Pilot Next episodeE3 · I Want Revenge

Seasons2

Season 1 Episodes9

Pilot still

Pilot

When We Were Young still

E2 5.1Now viewing

When We Were Young

I Want Revenge still

I Want Revenge

Everybody Dance Now still

Everybody Dance Now

This Is Me Trying still

This Is Me Trying

Divorce Is Like a Death still

Divorce Is Like a Death

Letting Go still

Letting Go

Oh, Jesus! still

Oh, Jesus!

Interior Law Offices still

Interior Law Offices

Cast7

Kim Kardashian

Kim Kardashian

Allura Grant

Naomi Watts

Naomi Watts

Liberty Ronson

Niecy Nash-Betts

Niecy Nash-Betts

Emerald Greene

Teyana Taylor

Teyana Taylor

Milan

Matthew Noszka

Matthew Noszka

Chase Munroe

Sarah Paulson

Sarah Paulson

Carrington Lane

Glenn Close

Dina Standish

Crew6

Ryan Murphy

Ryan Murphy

Writer

Anthony Hemingway

Anthony Hemingway

Director

Jamie Pachino

Jamie Pachino

Writer

Dimitris Giannetos

Dimitris Giannetos

Hairstylist

M

Mathew Hart

Co-Executive Producer

M

Mathew Hart

Unit Production Manager

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"When We Were Young" is episode 2 of All's Fair season 1. It scored 5.1/10 from 845 votes, ranking #8 of 9 episodes this season (season average 5.8). Directed by Anthony Hemingway and written by Ryan Murphy, Jamie Pachino, it aired on November 4, 2025.

Next: E3 · I Want Revenge Best of Season 1