Anna Pigeon backdrop

Anna Pigeon S1E9 — Nature vs Nurture

7.2

Anna Pigeon•Season 1•Episode 9

Nature vs Nurture

7.2/10 · 116 votesOct 2, 2026

Ranked #3 of 10 in Season 1•+0.1 vs season avg

A shooting hits close to home as Molly visits to find Anna's life more complicated than it seems.

Directed byLea Thompson

Written byNoelle Carbone

Previous episodeE8 · The Death Grin Next episodeE10 · SOS

Seasons1

Season 1 Episodes10

Track of the Cat still

Track of the Cat

Hide + Seek still

Hide + Seek

The Preacher still

The Preacher

Hell Is Other People still

Hell Is Other People

The Rope still

The Rope

There's Always a Road still

There's Always a Road

The Three Matt Skweikis still

The Three Matt Skweikis

The Death Grin still

The Death Grin

Nature vs Nurture still

E9 7.2Now viewing

Nature vs Nurture

SOS still

SOS

Cast9

Tracy Spiridakos

Tracy Spiridakos

Anna Pigeon

Paulina Alexis

Paulina Alexis

Zoey Bear Child

Ronnie Rowe

Ronnie Rowe

Frederick Stanton

Crystle Lightning

Crystle Lightning

Frieda Dierkz

Cooper Levy

Cooper Levy

Jesse Garland

Ryan Northcott

Ryan Northcott

Geoff Miller

Nikki Rae Hallow

Nikki Rae Hallow

Christina Clark

Manuel Rodriguez-Saenz

Manuel Rodriguez-Saenz

Manny López

Tricia Helfer

Tricia Helfer

Molly Pigeon

Crew2

Lea Thompson

Lea Thompson

Director

Noelle Carbone

Noelle Carbone

Writer

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"Nature vs Nurture" is episode 9 of Anna Pigeon season 1. It scored 7.2/10 from 116 votes, ranking #3 of 10 episodes this season (season average 7.1). Directed by Lea Thompson and written by Noelle Carbone, it aired on October 2, 2026.

Next: E10 · SOS Best of Season 1