When Ben’s first date with his new lover doesn’t go well, Danny and Riley step in to help sort out the couple’s issues, but their assistance quickly causes more harm than good. Tucker decides to tell his dad about his new relationship with Renee, one of his dad’s co-workers, but panics when he learns that his dad may have feelings for Renee too.

Ben and Riley learn the truth about Danny's feelings for Riley; Danny considers moving to Paris.

Tucker finds Zoey snooping around his apartment and assumes she is there for him, so he takes it upon himself to ask her out. However, Zoey believes Tucker is setting her up with Ben. Danny finds himself in a similar situation when he tries subtly asking Sam how he feels about Ben, but she thinks Danny is asking her out. And Riley finds herself in an uncomfortable situation when her client tries to take things to the next level with Bonnie. Are there any perfect matches?

As Ben and Riley both realize they are in for more than they bargained for with dating older, more mature adults, they work together to come up with a plan to get out of their respective relationships. When Bonnie and Tucker gain insider information about players on Danny’s hockey team, they bet against the Rangers to win some cash.

Ben throws a bash for Emma's first birthday and puts Tucker in charge of entertainment. Meanwhile, Ben encounters an ex-girlfriend who's hiding a big secret; and Danny uncovers shocking news about Riley's family.

A grumpy Ben wishes there was no such thing as Christmas, then is shocked when the fulfillment of his desire not only erases the holiday, but Emma's existence as well.

Tucker enlists Ben and Riley to appear on Mary Hart's program and reveal how they foiled an attempted mugging; Bonnie hopes to get rich by using Emma in a series of Internet videos.

While looking for a new bar manager, Ben interviews his old crush Sam, and decides to get revenge on her for never noticing him in high school. But things don’t turn out as planned.

Ben and the guys try to come up with the perfect babysitting schedule.

The boys are getting fed up with Bonnie always being at their apartment.

Megan’s dog is stolen while under Ben’s care. Riley tries to get her old job back with Bonnie’s help.

Ben and Riley try to jumpstart their relationship but Emma's mom, Angela, gets in the way. Tucker tries to help Danny get over his failed relationships.

Ben poses as Bonnie’s husband, Brad, when her friends from work don’t believe that she has an attractive, younger lover. When Danny begins dating a beautiful actress as a publicity stunt, Riley, who believes the relationship is real, decides to go back out with Ross to make Danny jealous. Tucker tries to further his entertainment reporting career by getting the real scoop on Danny and his new girlfriend.

Ladies man Ben has his life turned upside down when an ex leaves the daughter he never knew he had on his doorstep.

Danny plays matchmaker for Riley and his new teammate, who secretly likes Bonnie. Elsewhere, Tucker gets back together with an ex-girlfriend who doesn’t get along with Ben, and she winds up making Ben’s work life miserable.

Ben's new boss assumes him and Riley are married, so he convinces her to go along with it.

Riley goes a bit overboard when she becomes the captain of Ben's softball team.

Dr. Shaw determines Riley is the cause of Danny's inability to focus on the ice and bans her from Danny's next game. Meanwhile, Riley thinks things are moving too fast with Fitch and starts avoiding him, and gets her hopes up that Danny will make a move. Tucker is up for a promotion at work and his competition turns out to be Ben's latest fling, Jenna.

Emma’s mom, Angela, returns wanting to make amends with Ben and build a relationship with Emma.

When Ben learns that Sam’s living arrangements have fallen through, he schemes to push Danny and Riley to move in together so Sam can take his room.

Riley is frustrated that Ben only has eyes for Sam and not for Zoey, who she thinks is perfect for him.

When Tucker learns that his ex-girlfriend Sondra is newly single, he confides to Ben that she’s the “one that got away.” Ben offers to be Sondra’s rebound to tee Tucker up for success. Bonnie and Riley bond while camping out in a department store to score a sale on a crib. Danny tries to babyproof his and Riley’s apartment do-it-yourself style but seems to break more things than he can fix.

Ben tries to get a date with a hot nurse treating Emma.

Ben tries to clean up his act by taking a Mommy and Me class.

Ben, Danny and Tucker band together to rescue Emma's missing stuffed animal. Meanwhile, Riley hosts a book club in an effort to make friends with the cool girls at work. When her mom, Jennifer, and Bonnie get wind of her plans, they invite themselves. Much to Riley's dismay, the ladies' long-standing rivalry erupts during the club meeting.