As the season and series finale, actors Brandon Quinn, Danny Smith, and Aimée Castle host their own ""Best of"" Episode, featuring best episode, best villains (Male and Female), etc... and some outtakes and deleted scenes.

The reason for the losing streak of 75 years for Pleasantville against a team is because of a curse from Branco Nastovich, a player who smashed his head into a goal post. When Tommy runs through Bronco and scored a goal, Nasty goes after Tommy. Plus Lori gets expelled for the damage to her school's trophie case and now goes to Tommy and Merton's school.

While Merton was writing a new song for a song competition, Death returns for Tommy, but Merton and Tommy review all the good deeds that Tommy has done over the past 2 seasons.

Butch Jenkins is released from ""The Creature From The Atomic Lunar Crater...Returns!"" and now he is getting Lori to go with him back into the film.

Merton notices an attractive Japanese girl at the factory and falls for her. She actually is attracted to him but tells him that they are too different so they can never be together. Merton misinterprets this and learns all about Japanese culture in an attempt to whoo her. This also fails to win her over even though she obviously likes him. Merton steals a kiss from her and then his trouble begins. Lori reveals that the girl is actually a cursed girl from a fairy tale and that anyone who kisses her will be killed by an evil 900 year old samurai. In an amusing sub-plot Tommy has to do community service at the Hungry bucket.

When a man in a Santa Claus suit and a sleigh, the gang is convinced that he was Santa Claus, and they help him fix his sleigh before he entered the sky again. When he discover the real Santa Claus, the real one explains to Tommy, Merton, and Lori about what happened with him and his brother, Roger who stole the Santa suit, which contained magic that helps Santa Claus do all those amazing things. The gang teams up with Santa Claus to save Christmas from being ruined by his evil brother - the Anti-Claus.

An evil cyborg that looks a lot like Merton, from the future has been sent back to Pleasantville to kill Tommy. At school it blasts Tommy, but it seems that it was a GOOD cyborg from the future sent to protect Tommy Also the Merton cyborg poses for the school calendar and whose the photographer. Tommy teaches the Tommy cyborg to dance. They find out that now that the Tommy cyborg's mission is complete, he will self destruct and so will the Mertonator. But at the Hungry Bucket the Mertonator was on a date. I destroys the Tommy robot but Tommy destroys the Mertonator.

A transfer student comes to learn at the Pleasantville High School and Merton likes her, and Tommy tries to ask the girl to go with Merton, but she does not like Merton. When she found out that Tommy is a werewolf, she began to like Tommy. She was Medusa, a woman to turns people who crosses her into stone, and when she realizes that Tommy likes Lori, Medusa goes after her. Also Tommy finds Merton hugging Lori and gets mad. When Medusa is about to turn Tommy into stone Merton jumps in the way and is now a statue.

A princess from a kingdom of werewolves falls in love with Tommy, while Merton is attracted to her hunchbacked handmaiden.

A mysterious phantom, the ""Phantom of the Factory"" with his ""Mini-Me"" apprentice mistakenly thought that his long lost love had come back but it was actually Lori. He tried to get rid of all her lovers so that he can stay with her forever. While Merton aggressively pushed his theatrical masterpieces for a stage show. Rejected by the judges, he continued to develop his acting and musical skills to perform in the upcoming Pleasantville Musical concert. In the finale of this episode, a wonderful musical performance was acted out by Tommy, Merton, Lori, the Phantom of the Factory, and his sidekick.

When Merton finds a real superhero to join his new League of Decency, Tommy suspects that Stormfront is more interested in fame than in doing good deeds. Tommy and Lori decide to quit his ""team"" because Merton thinks they were the sidekicks of Stormfront because he was better than both of them. Stormfront causes havoc in the city of Pleasantville but he poses as a hero when he relinquishes the disaster. He also stole fame from Tommy Dawkins.

Merton began to look for a woman up above the stars after not being able to attract anyone on Earth. His interplanetary personal ad received a reply, and a visit from a mysterious alien leaves Merton pregnant. Lori is trying very hard to get into a college but Tommy and Merton kept interrupting them. Finally Tommy takes Lori and the Interviewer up to the space ship. Meaning another person finds out about Tommy and his and his friends' secret lives.

A girl who is obsesed with Lori switches bodies with her. Tommy and Merton don't believe Lori in Alices's body but become suspicious at Alice in Lori's body, because she doesn't know what 'wolf out' means. They become even more suspicious when 'Lori' cries. Their suspicions are confirmed when 'Alice' knows Tommy's sercret and 'Lori' doesn't. A subplot is Merton has his own tv show in which a guest star is an rival of his. 'Alice' 'Lori' and Tommy(wolfed out) crash it. Merton averts the camera. The strange creature that Mertons rival Fong (remember him?) brought gets removed from its own body by Alice, in Lori's body. Metron tells them that the three of them have to hold each others hands to undo what Alice did. With the help of Fong they get the three to hold hands. Lori pulls the creature from her body and the creature(what was it called?) pulls Alice from it's body and Alice disappears.

Merton tries to find new friends because he was rejected by Tommy, and these new friends try to fatten Merton up.

Merton finds a way to enter Tommy's head, and see all what Tommy sees, hear what all Tommy's thoughts were, and the ability to control Tommy's body - The Janitor's Closet. With this new discovery, Merton helps Tommy get Lori to get back together, and when Merton realized that he would use Tommy's werewolf powers to get revenge on a new student in school that has been threatening and bullying Merton, whose name was Bucky. After this defeat, Bucky noticed the secret entrance too and uses Tommy's werewolf body to get back at Merton, and now Merton, Lori, Tommy, and Bucky are in a battle in Tommy's head for control.

The demon comes to attack an innocent child, and Tommy and Merton decides this innocent child is Lester, so they try to hide Lester from the Demon, and then Tommy and Merton finds out that Lester is the Demon, and they must save Lori from being a sacrifice for Lester and stop the demons from inheriting the world.

While watching a boring and old educational film for detention, Tommy and Merton discovers that the bully from the movie, Butch got bored of his world and would like to enter the real world to capture a girl and take her back to the film, and the girl that he wanted was Stacey Hanson.

The Evil Werewolf Syndicate wants Tommy to join, whether he likes it or not. AND Lori finds out about Tommy's secret.

Lori gets Merton to revive her dead boyfriend but she did not expect what was going to happen next.

Merton's ex-girlfriend, Hilary Choate, was running for president of the school, and Merton was trying to ruin her campaign, and Hilary said to Merton that if she won, she would disband the ""Goth Club"", so he went to Tommy to make him start a campaign for president, running against Hilary, because he was very popular. When Hilary said to Mr. McGovern that she would give her soul to win the election, this tweaked Mr. McG's interest and made sure that Hilary had won the election, so he could enter her soul so he would not have to be thrown away by the captain in hell. Merton and Tommy must save her soul before Mr. McGovern takes her sould back into the underworld.

Merton noticed that Pleasantville once held a witch trial while fetching the basketball for a game between Tommy, Lori, Merton, Chuck and his friends. A conversation led to Merton saying that he had a girlfriend, and remembered the name of the witch who was burned at the stake. After repeating her name three times, she was released from the tree. Chuck told them that he wanted Merton to bring along his girlfriend to the Factory. Merton had to come up with a plan fast because he did not have a girlfriend but the witch came to the rescue, and she became Merton's girlfriend for a reward for releasing her from the tree. When the girl was getting on Merton's nerves, he had to break up with her, but Lori told Tommy and Merton that the witch had brutally killed her ex-boyfriends because they were trying to break up with her, and that was why she was burned to death.

A foreign exchange student named Carole enters Pleasantville High and Tommy decides to focus on her instead of Stacey but he does not know who to choose. Carole is a Cat Woman and she is jealous of Stacey and tries to destroy her.

When Merton reads the Egyptian print on the tomb of Bud, he is released from death and uses a teenager disguise while in public to search for a queen, and destroy the world. Tommy and Merton realized that the mummy has arisen from the dead and is trying to make Stacey his queen.

Merton was going to throw a party but no one would receive his invitations, plus Tommy and his buddies make fun of Merton, hurting his feelings. When Merton confronts him about it Tommy starts to 'wolf out' but Merton won't help. But accepts Tommy's help after a big announcement Tommy makes in the cafeteria. So Tommy helps him out on the appearance of theparty. Meanwhile, Merton's sister is possessed by a demon from a locker under the school. Merton gets caught but doesn't get in trouble because of 2 things. They were happy he was trying to fit in, and they get a hot tub.

A rogue cyborg guidance counsellor begins to implant devices into students' bodies.