Garfield runs away, and is nearly smothered by his new owner, who believes Garfield is her missing cat.

The Big Cock-A-Doodle puts Roy on trial for being a bad rooster. The other farm animals head over to clear Roy's name.

Garfield gets kicked out of the house and wanders into an alley, where an animal trainer tries to train him into a proper cat.

A saber-tooth tiger—one that should have been extinct millions of years ago—trades places with an unwittingly involved Garfield.

Jon finds his ideal match: Jane Arbinkle, who shares all of Jon's flaws as well.

When Roy accuses the others of not being able to take a joke, they begin to call him "Banana Nose", which hurts his feelings to the point where he leaves the farm. When he relies on his sense of smell to save Booker from a trap, he gains appreciation of his nose.

Orson reads Rumpelstiltskin to Booker and Sheldon, who (along with Wade and Roy) keep making changes to the story (e.g. showing a miller's son instead of a daughter and making the title character a superhero).

Jon buys a health food meal from an infomercial after going on a diet, only for it to be a scam. Garfield tries to get back at the advertiser.

A cricket named Ichabod agrees to be Garfield's conscience to help keep him out of trouble.

Jon has a job offer in Alaska that Garfield and Odie dislike, so they hire Ichabod to give Jon bad advice.

Jon goes on a date with a supermodel, who is instead interested in Garfield.

After Garfield is mean to Nermal, Jon sends him to a strict obedience school, where he is treated as a prisoner.

Orson, too sick to read Chicken Licken to Booker and Sheldon, has the rest of the farm try to help.

In a spoof of Johnny Appleseed, Jon plants ragweed plants, which makes people sneeze. A country singer narrates the story, which annoys Garfield.

When a dinosaur awakens in the present day, he plots to take over humanity by painting himself pink and hosting a Barney and Friends-type TV show. Everyone who watches Sidney the Pink Dinosaur becomes a babbling idiot who parrots everything Sidney says. Garfield is the only one left unaffected, and must devise a way to save the world.

Wade believes that the police will arrest him after he rips the tag off the bottom of a couch.

Garfield plays in a cardboard box, imagining himself driving a race car and flying an airplane. When Odie joins, he and Garfield imagine themselves stranded in the ocean.

In a poem rapped by Garfield, Odie wanders around the neighborhood and meets a tough dog named Butch and his flunkies.

Odie finds a magic wand tossed away by a magician. Garfield and Odie think that it is merely another stick.

When Garfield and Odie accidentally break his record player, Jon tries to find a new one.

In an effort to get married, Jon's cousin Roscoe looks for a job. Roscoe is hired to re-shingle the roof, mow the lawn, and vacuum the house, all of which result in the house being wrecked.

After getting her arrested, Garfield is cursed by a fortune teller.

Garfield must save Ludlow from another cat who attempts to eat him.

Garfield gives top ten lists on how he can tell he has had enough to eat, why Jon's dates end badly, things he hates to find on the table, and how a robbery will be foiled.

A wish on a shooting star causes Nermal and Garfield switch personalities for a day.