Cassie’s teaching position winds down and Sam is forced to take vacation time so they try out different hobbies together. Joy’s faced with a decision when Donna accepts a job for them in Vermont. Abigail and Donovan make one last stand against the curse.

Cassie pursues a temporary art history professorship while Sam diagnoses Adam. Abigail and Donovan realize that the missing diamond from the Middleton treasure may help break the curse.

As Cassie gets ready for Grey House’s 225th birthday Martha leads the group in a tableau vivant recreating a Nathaniel Merriwick painting, leading to new clues surrounding the Merriwick-Davenport curse. Joy experiences life differently when her intuition suddenly takes a holiday.

Cassie receives devastating news regarding the future of Bell, Book and Candle; the whole town comes together.

Cassie judges Middleton’s chili cook-off, which brings out fierce competition among residents, including Sam. Martha receives unexpected competition in her once-uncontested run for re-election. Cassie unearths a time capsule that reveals information about her current Grey House guest’s background.

Now empty-nesters, Cassie and Sam celebrate their first wedding anniversary. Abigail and Donovan’s relationship continues to be challenged by their families’ curse. Cassie’s Grey House guest has intentions for visiting Middleton that are different than she claims.

Cassie, Abigail and Joy browse an estate sale, where Joy hopes to find a clock for Martha's renovation. Stephanie's ex-husband, Wes, comes to town to pack up their shared cabin.

Martha fills in as the local Dear Debbie advice columnist, getting an anonymous letter that adds intrigue to a progressive dinner attended by all of the Middleton couples.

Cassie gives her art history students a lesson on perspective. Sam performs surgery on Adam, who worries about his recovery. Joy’s troubling dream about Abigail and Donovan may not be what it seems. Martha courts a French delegation to secure Middleton’s status as its sister city.

Cassie and Sam's much overdue date doesn't go as planned, and they end up stranded on an island.

Cassie welcomes a chocolate festival to Grey House where the confection has a special, sweet effect. Sam and Donovan discover a new clue surrounding the Merriwick-Davenport curse, while now-single Abigail gets an unexpected visit from a college friend for a surprising reason.

When Cassie and Sam’s weekend in Chicago gets canceled because Sam has to stay behind for work, she and her book club friends hit the road instead. While the ladies recharge the weekend also comes with surprises, including a potential clue about the Merriwick-Davenport curse.

A storm continues to threaten the lives of the people in Middleton and Cassie and Sam work together to help.

Cassie, Abigail and Joy learn the origins of the pouches of soil but have more questions than answers. Cassie and Sam's double date with hospital administrator Grant and his girlfriend, Monica, doesn't go quite as planned. All of Middleton flashes back to the '50s when Martha organizes a "Grease" themed movie night in the park that ends with a surprise romantic gesture.

Trouble is brewing after Cassie's mystery guest Ashley goes missing, and another pair of visitors to Middleton shake things up just in time for the town's annual heritage ball.

Cassie tries to convince Sam to follow her intuition in order to help a young couple survive a blizzard.

Middleton's Heritage Festival gets everyone talking; Cassie is back to her bewitching ways as she welcomes a scared young woman to the Grey House but she realizes she's being followed.

Cassie's mischievous cousin Abigail returns to Middleton, forcing Cassie to attempt tough love as Sam and Grace are swept up in Abigail's spell.

Cassie's magic can't keep her away from Abigail's scheming when the truth becomes too hard to hide and Abigail continues to stir the pot in Middleton.

Cassie can't help but feel upset after Grace admits she's been spending more time with Sam to replace the hurt she feels from the loss of her own late father.

Sam is excited to perform surgery on a star basketball player. Joy makes a discovery and decides to revive the Middleton Exchange tradition.

When Cassie, Abigail, and Joy toss coins into the historic wishing well, wishes old and new start coming true.

As the Merriwicks delve into the images on Joy's vision board, Cassie accompanies Sam on a trip to his childhood home to care for his sister.

After the death of her husband, Cassie Nightingale and her family find themselves caring for her ailing father-in-law. Moving in next door are the Radfords, Sam and Nick. Sam, the town's new doctor, has difficulty getting patients, as the town goes to Cassie's store for her more earthly herbal remedies.

Joy's dream sends the three Merriwicks on a search for Phillip Harper, Joy's father.