Nightmare Next Door backdrop

Nightmare Next Door poster

Crime•Documentary

The Best Seasons of Nightmare Next Door

Every season of Nightmare Next Door ever, ranked from best to worst by thousands of votes from fans of the show. The best seasons of Nightmare Next Door!

Binge this in Unknown•Peaking at 7.8/10

The tales of mysterious murders that rocked small-town America. Each hour brings you a new murder mystery and a new look into the evil that can lurk in the heart and soul of a tight-knit

Airs on

Investigation Discovery

#1

Season 9

10 Episodes

First Aired: Jul 2015

7.2/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE9 · Master Key Murder 7.7

#2

Season 3

5 Episodes

First Aired: Aug 2011

7.2/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE2 · Death in the Family 7.3

#3

Season 2

7 Episodes

First Aired: Jun 2011

7.1/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE7 · Skeletons in the Closet 7.4

Other Seasons

#4

Season 10

10 Episodes

First Aired: Sep 2016

7.1/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE8 · Everyone Has a Motive 7.8

#5

Season 1

6 Episodes

First Aired: Jan 2011

7.0/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE2 · The Truett Street Massacre 7.2

#6

Season 4

13 Episodes

First Aired: Jan 2012

7.0/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE12 · Double Murder Inferno 7.6

#7

Season 5

10 Episodes

First Aired: Jun 2012

6.9/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE1 · One Deadly Night 7.4

#8

Season 7

13 Episodes

First Aired: Mar 2013

6.4/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE9 · Drink With The Devil 6.9

#9

Season 6

7 Episodes

First Aired: Dec 2012

6.2/ 10

Average Rating

Best episodeE6 · Taste of Murder 6.9