Nightmare Next Door backdrop
Crime•Documentary

The Worst Episodes of Nightmare Next Door

Every episode of Nightmare Next Door ranked from worst to best. Explore the Worst Episodes of Nightmare Next Door!

Binge this in 2d 9h•Peaking at 7.8/10

The tales of mysterious murders that rocked small-town America. Each hour brings you a new murder mystery and a new look into the evil that can lurk in the heart and soul of a tight-knit

Airs on
Investigation Discovery
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons10

All12345678910

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Worst Episode
    Click to reveal
    Nightmare Next Door Season 4 Episode 20 - Memorial Day Murder
    0.0/10(0 votes)

    S4:E20

    A dream life ends when pretty mom-to-be Kelsey Monahon is found hogtied and beaten in her beachfront home.At first, the bizarre scene looks like a home invasion, but detectives dig deeper and turn up a trio of unlikely suspects including Kelsey's husband.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 7 - Last Call
    5.4/10(12 votes)

    S6:E7

    In late 2007, Jasper, TX, native Martin Byerly disappears without a trace. Police look into the 58-year-old ladies man's dance card but can't seem to pin anything on a femme fatal. Then an unlikely tipster helps them learn what happened to Martin.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. Nightmare Next Door Season 5 Episode 10 - Devils in the Details
    5.6/10(14 votes)

    S5:E10

    The 1991 savage rape and murder of 22-year-old Cindy Pavey, single mom of 2, rattles the tranquil town of Murphysboro, IL. Police investigate a potentially deadly love triangle, but it will take 17 years to harvest the leads necessary to bring her killer to justice.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 7 - Out Of The Past
    5.8/10(16 votes)

    S7:E7

    After 16-year-old Sherita Williams takes a quick trip to the nail salon in Pennsauken, NJ, she is sexually assaulted, strangled to death and dumped under a bridge in 2003. Police dig up a cast of potential villains but the case goes cold. When the true killer finally appears through a DNA match 4 years later, they find he's in a class all his own.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 1 - Dead of the Night
    5.9/10(17 votes)

    S6:E1

    When beloved store manager 47-year-old Mary Peterson is found stabbed to death in her bed in 1995, storm clouds brew over sunny Lakeland, FL. Cops race through a lengthy list of suspects, but a tip from an unlikely source helps nab the cold-blooded killer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 2 - Prescription for Murder
    5.9/10(12 votes)

    S6:E2

    On April 15, 2004, residents of Riverton, WY are worried about more than the IRS after the brutal murder of 39-year-old prison nurse, wife and mom Tammy Watts. Police begin an all out manhunt for the killer and it takes a hair-raising discovery for them to nab their guy.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 BEST Episodes of Nightmare Next Door

    READ
  7. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 4 - Million Dollar Murder
    5.9/10(11 votes)

    S7:E4

    On May 22, 2004, Baton Rouge, LA, self-made millionaire Alan Waters, a divorced father of 2, is found shot to death inside his mansion. Police think his real estate business is to blame but they can't solve this deadly puzzle until someone close to Alan comes forward with the missing piece.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 5 - Deadly Intentions
    6.1/10(11 votes)

    S6:E5

    The tight-knit community of eastside Buffalo, NY is stunned in 1994 when the body of beautician and single mom Cynthia Epps is found stuffed into a cabinet placed in a neighbor's backyard next to a vacant lot cut-through; she had been raped, stabbed and nearly decapitated. A clever killer eludes capture for 16 years, but new technology and dogged detective work put him behind bars.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  9. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 5 - Cruel Intentions
    6.1/10(14 votes)

    S7:E5

    In Lanett, AL, things just aren't adding up when 49-year-old Charlotte Waites, a beloved former teacher and mayor's wife, is found dead in her home in 1998. Friends try to put two and two together, but they come up with zero reasons anyone would want her dead, and police are just as stymied.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  10. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 8 - Country Killing
    6.1/10(11 votes)

    S7:E8

    In early fall of 1992, the rural community of Wantage, NJ, is rocked by the murder of beloved local Christine Schurman. Police are at a loss for suspects until a tip about another murder committed in Missouri connects them to their killer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  11. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 12 - Where There's Smoke
    6.2/10(13 votes)

    S7:E12

    Joliet, IL, firefighters are shocked to find 28-year-old Melissa Plut strangled to death when they respond to a fire in her duplex. Police search the maternity nurse's love life with no luck until a 9-1-1 call unmasks her killer hiding in plain sight.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  12. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 13 - Murder In Paradise
    6.2/10(14 votes)

    S7:E13

    When pretty Nags Head, NC, tourist Janet Siclari turns up dead on the beach outside her hotel, the fun comes to an end. When a hurricane blows leads out of town, police wonder if the killer escaped too. Only time can help detectives catch the culprit.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  13. Nightmare Next Door Season 4 Episode 11 - Little Girl Lost
    6.3/10(18 votes)

    S4:E11

    On July 4, 1996, 9-year-old Cyndi Allinger doesn't show up for dinner and her mom fears the worst. Is a predator stalking the school-age children of scenic Lakewood, WA? The most likely tip comes from the least likely witnesses, and leads to Cyndi's killer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  14. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 10 - Murders Under The Mistletoe
    6.3/10(11 votes)

    S7:E10

    Holiday cheer ends in holiday fear, when Jean Wholaver and her two daughters are murdered in their home on Christmas Eve. Detectives in Middletown, PA, check their list of suspects twice and are shocked by the killer's true identity.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  15. Nightmare Next Door Season 9 Episode 8 - Murder In Omaha
    6.3/10(15 votes)

    S9:E8

    When stage actress Pasinetta Prince is found strangled to death in her home, the close-knit community of North Omaha, NE is left reeling. As police dig deeper into the life of the beautiful starlet, they find a long line of admirers who are possible suspects.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  16. Nightmare Next Door Season 10 Episode 2 - The Unwelcome Wagon
    6.3/10(16 votes)

    S10:E2

    When Staff Sgt. Michael Severance goes AWOL the community of San Angelo, TX, rallies around his new bride. But there is something more sinister behind his disappearance, and investigators uncover a saga of treachery and passion as big as the state of Texas.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  17. Nightmare Next Door Season 7 Episode 2 - Devil in the Desert
    6.4/10(9 votes)

    S7:E2

    When divorcee Adele Curtis, a mom of 5 adult children, meets a terrible end in her Phoenix, AZ, rental property in 1996, detectives delve into a series of suspects to find the killer. But when the search goes cold as a desert night, it takes the dawn of DNA to catch this murderer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  18. Nightmare Next Door Season 4 Episode 3 - Trouble in Tulsa
    6.5/10(16 votes)

    S4:E3

    When accountant and two-time divorcee Geraldine 'Jerry' Martin goes missing, and is later found viciously murdered and mutilated in 1975, the city of Tulsa, OK, is left in fear. With no solid leads, it takes detectives more than 25 years and new DNA evidence more than 1000 miles away to warm up this cold case.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  19. Nightmare Next Door Season 5 Episode 7 - Deadly Dealings
    6.5/10(14 votes)

    S5:E7

    The quiet town of Tomahawk, WI, is rocked when long time resident 42-year-old grandmother Tracy Maurer is found brutally stabbed to death in her home. Police have a laundry list of suspects but it's a tip from the rumor mill that finally brings closure to the case.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  20. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 3 - Murder on the Menu
    6.5/10(13 votes)

    S6:E3

    When friendly cashier Tammy Petrin is found shot execution style at the local burger joint in 1991, the town of Woonsocket, RI, is in shock. After lead suspects don't serve up answers, a helpful hooker and letters from jail might be just what detectives ordered.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  21. Nightmare Next Door Season 6 Episode 4 - Wrong Way Home
    6.5/10(15 votes)

    S6:E4

    When 12-year-old Michelle Winter goes missing without a trace while walking back from her best friend's house in Springfield, MO in 1995, her mom doesn't have a clue as to who could have whisked this pre-teen away. Cops have many leads, but it isn't until evidence is linked to the killer that they get their big break.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  22. Nightmare Next Door Season 10 Episode 5 - Death Takes a Toll
    6.5/10(17 votes)

    S10:E5

    Michael Zammitti Jr. has it all - a loving family, a thriving business, and a comfortable home. But when he is found shot to death at his office desk, police must untangle a web of corruption and lies that will rock two small New England towns to their core.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  23. Nightmare Next Door Season 2 Episode 4 - Sea of Hate
    6.6/10(19 votes)

    S2:E4

    When single mom Norma Rodriguez's murder in 1993 hits the town of Port Hueneme, CA, police are left sorting out the suspects in its wake. It will take a capricious witness and 10 years to clean up the damage. When the dust finally settles no one is more surprised than the killer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  24. Nightmare Next Door Season 4 Episode 2 - House of Horror
    6.6/10(21 votes)

    S4:E2

    The bloody murder of Beth Grosskopf in 2009 leaves the town of Freedom, PA, riddled with fear. Hopes for quick justice are dashed when the initial suspects don't pan out. But when someone reveals his inner demons, cops move in to catch the killer.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  25. Nightmare Next Door Season 4 Episode 4 - The Lady Killer
    6.6/10(18 votes)

    S4:E4

    When 25-year-old Amy St. Laurent disappears after a night out on the town in 2001, the people of Portland, ME, are terrified. With no body, police don't know what to make of it. But their worst fears are confirmed when a shocking discovery proves murder.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Worst Episodes Summary

"Memorial Day Murder" is the worst rated episode of "Nightmare Next Door". It scored /10 based on 0 votes. Directed by Unknown and written by Unknown, it aired on 6/20/2014. This episode scored 5.4 points lower than the second lowest rated, "Last Call".