The Worst Episodes of Popular

Episode Rankings

1. #1 Worst Episode
   Click to reveal

   REVEAL THE WORST
   

   6.4/10(100 votes)

   #1 - Fag

   S2:E163/9/2001

   Lily, in an effort to defend a fellow student who has been suffering jokes about his lifestyle, starts the G.L.A.S.S. (Gay and Lesbian Alliance of Supportive Students), which causes a lot of repercussion around the school, and not such great support from people as she expected. But prejudice is not only about sexual choices, as Sam and George have to deal with the comments on their interracial relationship; Sugar D. doesn't get a job for being fat and Jamie (Brooke's date) reveals that he has suffered prejudice because of his religion. Things get hot when Lily is hospitalized after being attacked when she was leaving a g/l community center (which she took Miss Glass to get information about her sexuality). The gang realizes that hate will never lead to anything, and join the group one by one. Bryan comes out of the closet in a gesture of support after the group is cancelled.

   Director:Elodie Keene

   Writer:Deidre Strohm

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Elodie Keene

   Writer:Deidre Strohm
2. 

   7.2/10(75 votes)

   #2 - The Shocking Possession of Harrison John

   S2:E121/26/2001

   After Harrison returns to school since he had his bone marrow transplant, he acts in a weird way, making everybody think he's possessed or something. The girls think about it and conclude that he has impersonated Nicole's personality, since she was the donor. They decide to call a priest to exorcise him. Meanwhile, Josh and Lily's relationship is growing so much that there's hardly any space left for Sugar Daddy in Josh's life. Feeling neglected, he finds a new friendship in George. They enjoy each other for a while until George feels like Sugar is demanding too much attention. Josh and Sugar make up. Nicole finds out she's adopted after she asks her mom about her birth and she doesn't give clear information. Shocked, Nicole finds out that her mom was a 16 year old cheerleader, and tries to find her with no luck. Both Nicole and Harrison conclude they have to find themselves.

   Director:Jamie Babbit

   Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Jamie Babbit

   Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz
3. 

   7.4/10(93 votes)

   #3 - Two Weddings and a Funeral

   S1:E225/18/2000

   Bobbi Glass ruins the annual "skip day" ritual for the popular and alternative kids by faxing their photos to their favorite hangouts so they'll be caught cutting classes. The kids plot their revenge during an extended musical number. Meanwhile, Sam and Brooke agree to work together to make their parents' rehearsal dinner a success.

   Director:Lev L. Spiro

   Writer:Ryan Murphy

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Lev L. Spiro

   Writer:Ryan Murphy
4. 

   7.4/10(73 votes)

   #4 - The Sweetest Taboo

   S2:E410/13/2000

   Nicole, desperate to get back to the Glamazons, tries to bribe and blackmail Principal Krupps. Her attempts fail and she gets Mary Cherry and Sugar Daddy to help her make a fake video about him. As a result, she gets terminated from the cheerleaders forever. A new kid joins Kennedy High and gets a spot on the football team. Josh, jealous of him, tries to put everybody else against him. He gets his mom a job at school and she starts to date the football coach, and Josh's life falls apart. Sam misjudges George but realizes that friendship is more worth than an article. Josh finds Nicole crying, a proof that she still has a human side. They console each other.

   Director:Craig Zisk

   Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Craig Zisk

   Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner
5. 

   7.5/10(81 votes)

   #5 - Timber!

   S2:E19/22/2000

   Brooke bonds with her long-lost mother--much to her dad's chagrin. Meanwhile, Lily and Sugar Daddy try to save a tree from being cut down, and Carmen delays telling her friends about her pregnancy.

   Director:Jamie Babbit

   Writer:Ryan Murphy

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Jamie Babbit

   Writer:Ryan Murphy
6. 

   7.5/10(80 votes)

   #6 - Are You There God? It's Me, Ann-Margret

   S2:E912/8/2000

   Josh and Lily get cast for a play at the school where they have to appear nude in front of each other and everyone, which makes them uncomfortable. Brooke is at hospital again for treatment for her anorexia. Harrison is frightened when he walks into a room in the hospital and finds a ghost who seems to know a lot about him. Meanwhile, Carmen runs into Nicole in a metting for teenagers with alcoholic parents, but Nicole totally ignores her.

   Director:Unknown

   Writer:Oliver Goldstick

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Unknown

   Writer:Oliver Goldstick
TRENDING NOW
The 20 BEST Episodes of Popular
READ
7. 

   7.5/10(72 votes)

   #7 - Mary Charity

   S2:E132/2/2001

   Mary Cherry's clothes and objects are confiscated at school because her mom declared bankruptcy. She mutates into a crappy looking teen trash, with KFC's heat and paper shoes. Lily tries to help her and Mary Cherry starts to work at the cafeteria. Lily shows her how it really feels like to be poor. Meanwhile, Sam and Carmen decide to make a campaign to encourage people to take the pictures for the yearbook, and April is one of the only people who candidate for the free makeup. What started out as an experiment on a person's outside appearance turns out to be a lesson in the importance of what is inside a person. Brooke and Harrison are finally free from the hospital and Harrison tries to convince Brooke to take the school pictures. They have a moment while joking around deciding what to wear. Brooke and Harrison agree to stay just friends, Sam and Carmen experiment turns out a success and Mary Cherry gets her stuff back, and helps the needy.

   Director:Lawrence Trilling

   Writer:James Duff

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Lawrence Trilling

   Writer:James Duff
8. 

   7.5/10(78 votes)

   #8 - The Brain Game

   S2:E184/27/2001

   Desperately seeking to be popular again, Mary Cherry fails in an audition to a teen talent show. But that didn't stop her, and she decides to put a team of students together to be in ""The Big Head Challenge"". Everybody is studying for the SATs and they all think it would be a nice way to test their knowledge at this competition. Cherry Cherry, who has become a student at KH (trying to beat her 50 points score in her SAT), also tries to get in, but loses the very last spot to Josh, who surprisingly know a lot more about chicken than we thought. Meanwhile, Carmen decides to take salsa lessons, and has her heart broken by the instructor, whom she had a crush for. But after he realizes how bad he made Carmen feel, he goes to KH to ask her out. At the competition, the gang is first relieved to be against the John Ashcroft Private School for Special Needs Children, but then surprised when they see that Cherry Cherry has bought the entire team and replaced the students by the teen talent show

   Director:Craig Zisk

   Writer:James Duff

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Craig Zisk

   Writer:James Duff
9. 

   7.6/10(81 votes)

   #9 - Lord of the Files

   S1:E172/24/2000

   A new vice-principal joins Kennedy High and his good looks draw the attention of the female students. Meanwhile, Brooke lies to Carmen about a tattoo she claims was inspired by Josh, so Carmen suspects that Brooke may want her old beau back; and Emory tells Harrison that a grade-school music teacher was once impressed with Harrison's music skills.

   Director:Lev L. Spiro

   Writer:Oliver Goldstick

   Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

   Director:Lev L. Spiro

   Writer:Oliver Goldstick
10. 

    7.6/10(79 votes)

    #10 - We Are Family

    S1:E205/4/2000

    Brooke and Sam try to derail their parents' wedding plans by planting false evidence of Mike's infidelity, which leads to a startling announcement from Mike and Jane. Meanwhile, Mary Cherry discovers that her mother is engaged to actor Erik Estrada.

    Director:Elodie Keene

    Writers:Ryan Murphy, Deidre Strohm

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Elodie Keene

    Writers:Ryan Murphy, Deidre Strohm
11. 

    7.6/10(76 votes)

    #11 - Style and Substance Abuse

    S2:E611/3/2000

    Brooke decides to run for student council president, dropping out of the Homecoming Queen election. She asks Harrison to be her campaign manager. They disagree on mandatory drug testing for students and he quits to run against her. Sam, Carmen, Nic and Mary Cherry get nominated to Homecoming Queen. Sam is motivated by George to run for it, but gets too into the spirit. Carmen is sleeping at the school since she is homeless, and Bobbi Glass invites her to her home. Seeing in Carmen herself in high school, Ms. Glass helps her with the contest (even threatening to give everybody an F if they don't vote for Carmen). Nic and Mary Cherry look for help with Hellacious Arke, a past 3 time Homecoming Queen, who is also Ms. Glass's own ""Nicole"" back in her high school days. Brooke misses Josh and sees him and Lily trying cough syrup while spying on them. Motivated by the recent death of a student of cough syrup overdose, she decides to run her campaign on anti-drug platform. Scared to be caught

    Director:Elodie Keene

    Writer:Ryan Murphy

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Elodie Keene

    Writer:Ryan Murphy
12. 

    7.6/10(109 votes)

    #12 - Misery Loathes Company

    S2:E811/17/2000

    Harrison is checked in a hospital for treatment for his leukemia. His roommate is a religious fanatic, which makes him quite uncomfortable. Harrison doesn't want anybody's help and yells at Brooke. Brooke is faced with the ghost of her anorexia and fears coming back to the clinic she once was. Sugar Daddy feels miserable for his looks and checks into a clinic for food disorders (which happens to be the same hospital where Harrison is.). Mike hears somebody throwing up in the bathroom. First he thinks it might be Jane, but he realizes it's Brooke and puts her in the clinic. Sugar feels very depressed and has a fight with Brooke. Later she advises him to talk to one of the girls at the clinic, and she plays cupid slipping a love letter under her door. But the clinician gets the letter instead. Sugar feels guilty and tells Ashley that he didn't write the letter, without knowing that she never got the letter in the first place. Harrison's roommate has a seizure, just as he was starting to

    Director:Craig Zisk

    Writers:Deidre Strohm, Oliver Goldstick

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Craig Zisk

    Writers:Deidre Strohm, Oliver Goldstick
13. 

    7.6/10(67 votes)

    #13 - Coup

    S2:E173/16/2001

    With a lot of power in her hands and not so many brain cells in her head, April Tuna is ordered by Principal Krupps to cut one of the school's clubs. April becomes an easy prey for Evil Nicole (still out of the Glamazons and thirsty for revenge), who manipulates her into cutting the Glamazons off. April and Emory have a small fight when she threats to cut the ""John Travolta-inspired Staying Alive"" club, for which Lily, Harrison and Josh compete to be president of. Meanwhile, Brooke gets in deep trouble after she doesn't come home from Jamie's, which causes Mike to get furious and ground both Sam and her for lying. After Jane talks to him, he finally decides to give Jamie a chance and invites him over for dinner. Back at KH, Emory blackmails Tuna in order to save his club, and she ends up losing the position of student body president to Nicole, who immediately cuts the Glamazons, replaces it with ""Bring It!"", the new pep squad with her as the big star, and shuts the John Travolta club,

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner
14. 

    7.6/10(73 votes)

    #14 - You Don't Tug On Superman's Cape...You Don't Spit Into The Wind...You Don't Pull The Mask Off The Ol' Lone Ranger...

    S2:E205/11/2001

    Sam and Brooke have a quick but intense argument over what each one has done to/with Harrison. Sam does not forgive Brooke for having slept with him, and Brooke puts Sam against the wall saying Sam turned him down so there were no strings attached. They both realize none of them is really wrong, and if there's anyone wrong there it's Harrison. At school, they give him the cold shoulder and George does the same to Sam. Sam and Brooke plan to stood up Harrison at a restaurant, but Brooke shows up and is caught by Sam talking to Harrison, which leads into a huge food fight. At home, Jane is trying to fix things between the two of them when her water breaks. Josh's mom announces she is moving away, and Josh has to either come with her or go live with his dad - which he does in order not to leave Lily. She suggests they get married, and although his mom tried to warn him that he was too young, he goes ahead and gets married to Lily right before prom. Mary Cherry accidentally bumps into Big

    Director:Lawrence Trilling

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Lawrence Trilling

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz
15. 

    7.7/10(72 votes)

    #15 - Citizen Shame

    S2:E310/6/2000

    Bobbi Glass's uncle Tipton is coming to town, and she has to find a solution for her lies. All these years she has been telling him about her child, which she doesn't have. He is rich and she wants his money. So she bribes Nicole to pretend to be her daughter. Carmen runs away from home because she is having family problems. Her father left and she has bruises on her arm. She stays with Sam and Jane for a while, but then Jane talks her into calling her mom. She doesn't want Carmen to come back anymore, and Carmen is thinking about getting her own place. Trying to help Carm with money, Lily shows up at the family lunch and poses as Bobbi's second daughter. Bobbi's plans are ruined and nobody gets the money. Meanwhile, Bonnie, the new SAT teacher, becomes friendly with Brooke and they have lunch together. She gets drunk and Brooke tries to drive her home, but she takes the wrong car by accident and gets in major trouble. Jane and Sam have to take her out of prison. And then Jane realizes

    Director:Lev L. Spiro

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Lev L. Spiro

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick
16. 

    7.7/10(71 votes)

    #16 - Fire in the Hole

    S2:E111/19/2001

    Sam decides to take her relationship with George to the next level, and he gets scared and says they should wait until they're both ready. Bobbi Glass decides to make all her students act in a play she wrote herself (""That Burning Sensation: A Cautionary Tale"") about STDs, as a part of the ""National STDs Week"". The students are cast: Lily as gonorrhea; April as syphilis; Josh and SD are worrisome warts; Mary Cherry and Nicole are crabs; Brooke is herpes; Carm is unsightly yellow discharge and Sam gets the part as the whore, with Harrison (now back at school) as the lonely virgin. Josh and Sugar decide to give Harrison a ""virgin certificate"", since he is the only virgin boy in the group, but he gets offended and embarrassed. Instead of taking the certificate, he decides to ask Nicole to sleep with him, but she says no. so he decides to use his certificate, but the prostitute is so old that they decide just to have Chinese food instead. Lily runs into George at a clinic and finds out he

    Director:Randall Miller

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Randall Miller

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner
17. 

    7.7/10(73 votes)

    #17 - It's Greek to Me

    S2:E153/2/2001

    Nicole's mom is not so happy about her spending time with her birth mom. Judy Julian tries to bribe Nicole's mom so she would disappear. Shaggy leaves and Nicole and Judy become closer. Meanwhile, the girls are bored with the immature behavior of the boys and their boring lives as high school students. Brooke meets a college girl who invites them to a college party. Sam and Lily are stuck at home for lying about where they where going and spend up playing board games with Sam's parents all night. Carmem meets a boy and goes up to his room. Feeling that something might happen, she hides inside the closet until the boys come to rescue her. After their experience at the frat party, the group learns that high school isn't so bad after all.

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz
18. 

    7.8/10(98 votes)

    #18 - Under Siege

    S1:E310/7/1999

    Sam writes an exposé about the cheerleaders' school budget, leading to the squad's termination and its remaining funds being redistributed to the drama department. The exposé also heightens the tension between Brooke and Sam as they prepare for their first dinner together with their parents. Meanwhile, Josh must decide between starring in the school musical or playing in the homecoming game.

    Director:Perry Lang

    Writer:Ryan Murphy

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Perry Lang

    Writer:Ryan Murphy
19. 

    7.8/10(91 votes)

    #19 - Windstruck

    S1:E410/14/1999

    Sam and Josh have an embarrassing encounter during a play rehearsal, starting rumors that they are interested in each other. Meanwhile, Brooke confesses to Nicole that she and Josh are still virgins, and Harrison's hope for a relationship with Brooke gets a boost when she turns to him for comfort.

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick
20. 

    7.8/10(82 votes)

    #20 - What Makes Sammy Run

    S1:E215/11/2000

    Sam runs away from home and hunts for Brooke's mother, with the hope that the woman will help her put an end to Mike and Jane's wedding plans. Meanwhile, Josh, Sugar Daddy, Harrison and Emory Dick go to a strip club with fake IDs.

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Jamie Babbit

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz
21. 

    7.8/10(74 votes)

    #21 - Baby, Don't Do It!

    S2:E29/29/2000

    Bobbi Glass (with her new nickname, Claws) has a new experiment for the students: they have to take care of baby dolls as if they were real babies. Everybody gets one, except for Lily who shares the doll with Carm. Because they don't know the baby's gender, they name it Hillary Swank - neither a boy nor a girl. Brooke is too busy because she is moving to San Francisco with her mom, and doesn't have time to take care of the doll. Emory's twin sisters, Emma and Emily (Em&Em, a parody of the rap singer Eminem) come to K. High looking for lessons from Nic and MC for how to become popular. Too busy teaching the girls and organizing a party that will define popularity, they handle their babies to a British nanny, who eventually abuses them. Carm, concerned about the unpopular group, decides to help them, but neglects her baby. The twins become too powerful and turn against their teachers. Nic and Mary Cherry decide it's time to stop them and put things back on track. Meanwhile, Sam decides t

    Director:Michael M. Robin

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Michael M. Robin

    Writers:Edward Kitsis, Adam Horowitz
22. 

    7.8/10(84 votes)

    #22 - I Know What You Did Last Spring Break!

    S2:E195/4/2001

    Ms. Glass wants all the students to write down where did they go for Spring Break and how many they slept with, so, in her own words, she can judge them. Most of the gang say they went to Cancun, and Harrison writes that he went to Yemen as his nose starts to bleed. Ms. Glass deduces he has been infected with the Rift Valley fever that is contaminating everyone in Yemen. Just as Sam was trying to talk to him by his locker, they are both isolated from the rest of the people and the school is shut down in quarantine. During Chemistry, Mary Cherry receives a call in her cell phone from someone who knows what she really did for Spring Break - a low-budget soft porn scary movie - and she has to run for her life as she is chased to be killed. Meanwhile, Lily tells April what they really did for SB. They intended to go to Cancun, but they all stayed in LA and had SB in different ways. Nicole is elected to attract the killer, but since she's not a virgin, and only virgins get chased by killers

    Director:Ryan Murphy

    Writer:Ryan Murphy

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Ryan Murphy

    Writer:Ryan Murphy
23. 

    7.9/10(99 votes)

    #23 - Slumber Party Massacre

    S1:E510/21/1999

    Members of the cheerleading squad agree to attend Carmen's slumber party, causing Sam to question their motives. At the party, Nicole tries to impress Carmen's older brother, Leo, and a party game takes a disturbing turn.

    Director:Michael M. Robin

    Writer:Wendy MacLeod

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Michael M. Robin

    Writer:Wendy MacLeod
24. 

    7.9/10(91 votes)

    #24 - Truth or Consequences

    S1:E611/4/1999

    Sam discovers that Nicole, Poppy and Mary Cherry stole the answers to the biology midterm, and she sets out to gather the evidence she needs to turn them in. Meanwhile, Mike and Jane's sneaking around angers Brooke and Sam.

    Director:Marc Buckland

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Marc Buckland

    Writers:Eric Preven, Ari Posner
25. 

    7.9/10(89 votes)

    #25 - Wild Wild Mess

    S1:E912/2/1999

    The students embark on finding nominees for "Principal for the Day," while a custodial strike leaves the school a mess. Meanwhile, Brooke fears she may be pregnant; and Sam, Carmen and Lily discover something personal about Harrison's mother.

    Director:Lev L. Spiro

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    Director:Lev L. Spiro

    Writer:Oliver Goldstick