Why did Danner really leave the police force? She presents the scintillating story to Aniq like a steamy '90s thriller.

Yasper explains how he tried to get Xavier to help him get his music career off the ground. His version of the events is a toe-tapping musical.

Zoë confesses she came to the reunion for a wild night out—a break from her divorced, single-mom life. Things get animated in her retelling.

When Zoe's sister's wedding weekend is destroyed by a murder, Aniq calls his old friend Danner to investigate the crime.

Aniq and Danner interview the bride, who tells the story of her relationship with Edgar in the style of a Jane Austen romance.

Aniq and Danner move the investigation to Zoe's family, starting with her free-spirited uncle. His tale is an epic, global romance.

Following a shocking death at a high school reunion's afterparty, Detective Danner grills Aniq, who recounts the night like a rom-com.

Grace's former boyfriend tells his story like a film noir: He suspected that Edgar was up to no good and was determined to protect his ex.

Chelsea reveals her not-so-innocent motive: revenge, plain and simple. Her recollection is a tense psychological thriller.

Everyone's stories trace back to a high school party from 15 years ago, which Walt recounts to Detective Danner—revealing huge secrets.

As her unconventional methods land her in hot water, Detective Danner looks to her own past to explain why she needs to crack this case.

When Edgar's business partner opens up about their complicated history, it plays like a slick and suspenseful heist movie.

Zoe's father reluctantly agrees to sit with her, Aniq, and Danner as they review found-footage-style videos from the weekend.

In Brett's action-packed retelling of the night, he had one goal in attending the reunion: reconcile with his ex-wife to get their family back together.

Like the heroine of a twee indie film, Edgar's adopted sister wanted to stop the wedding because of her own broken heart.

Alternating between campy horror and '80s soap opera, Zoe and her mother fill in the remaining blanks of Edgar's murder.

An unexpected eyewitness emerges to help Detective Danner piece together the true story behind Xavier’s demise. Season finale.

Launching into a '50s psychological melodrama, Edgar's mother details her nightmarish year since the death of her husband.