The Best Episodes of ER Season 5
Every episode of ER Season 5 ranked from best to worst. Discover the Best Episodes of ER Season 5!
ER explores the inner workings of an urban teaching hospital and the critical issues faced by the dedicated physicians and staff of its overburdened emergency room.
Season 5 Ratings Summary
The best episode of "ER" season 5 is "Day for Knight", rated 7.8/10 from 450 user votes. It was directed by Christopher Chulack and written by Lydia Woodward. "Day for Knight" aired on 9/24/1998 and is rated 0.1 point(s) higher than the second highest rated, "Split Second".
7.8/10 450 votes#1 - Day for Knight
Season 5 Episode 1 - Aired 9/24/1998
Third-year med student Lucy Knight reports to the ER for the first day of her rotation. Greene takes a teacherly interest in her, helping her get acquainted, but she gets off to a bad start with the irritable Carter when she speaks insensitively, and without Carter present, with a patient's wife about her husband's very serious condition. The rest of the day finds her comforting a woman who has suffered a miscarriage, getting locked out on the roof, having Carol bail her out on a simple procedure, and trying to figure out Kerry Weaver's "Tour on Tape."
Director: Christopher Chulack
Writer: Lydia Woodward
7.7/10 399 votes#2 - Split Second
Season 5 Episode 2 - Aired 10/1/1998
Dr. Corday's father visits from overseas in an attempt to convince her to join his medical practice. Weaver suggests that Elizabeth look into alternative methods to stay in America, like starting over as an intern. Weaver also doesn't let an opportunity pass to remind Doug of the way he bypassed her authority in the McLean case. Lucy continues learning, earning more of Carter's respect than she deserves. Peter takes Reese in for another hearing test. Mark has several discussions with paramedics about the state of the EMT program. Carol hires a nurse practitioner to help out in the clinic. Carter is having trouble being an RA in the dorms.
Director: Christopher Misiano
Writer: Carol Flint
7.6/10 408 votes#3 - They Treat Horses, Don't They?
Season 5 Episode 3 - Aired 10/8/1998
Mark goes to a trauma scene with the EMTs, where he treats a gunshot victim who has a bomb strapped to himself. Later, Mark’s daughter persuades him to treat a horse with colic, and Jerry gets the bad end of the enema. Carter intubates an elderly woman who is DNR. When her HMO declines to admit her, Carter either has to find a relative quickly or let her die. Kerry finds herself more and more frustrated when Anspaugh suggests that they're not considering her for ER Chief, and she discovers she’s the last to hear that Doug was made a pediatric attending. Corday serves her last day as a surgical fellow. Benton meets with Carla to discuss getting Reese hearing aids. Jeanie returns from vacation. Carter goes out with Roxanne, the insurance saleswoman he treated.
Director: Babu Subramaniam
Writer: Walon Green
7.6/10 401 votes#4 - Vanishing Act
Season 5 Episode 4 - Aired 10/15/1998
Dr. Corday begins her first day as an intern, first by being assigned to Dale Edson, then being treated as Romano's lapdog. Kerry is interviewed for ER chief. Doug and Carol ponder parenthood when Carol realizes she may be pregnant. Carol and Lynette try to keep a wounded gang-banger from leaving and seeking retaliation. Lucy faces the wrath of Carter when he discovers that she doesn't know how to start an IV. Jeanie asks Doug if she can be a full-time PA for the pediatric ER.
Director: Lesli Linka Glatter
Writer: Jack Orman
7.9/10 416 votes#5 - Masquerade
Season 5 Episode 5 - Aired 10/29/1998
Halloween night finds the ER awash with allergic or otherwise incapacitated children. Kerry tolerates a visiting candidate for chief while she waits for the official vote. Romano operates on an 11-year-old girl and finds she's genetically male. Carter leaves Lucy in charge of a dorm party he's supposed to be overseeing, with unfortunate results. Mark learns that Jenn's moving to St. Louis--with Rachel. Mark and Carol treat a pregnant schizophrenic.
Director: Steve De Jarnatt
Writer: Samantha Corbin-Miller
7.8/10 407 votes#6 - Stuck on You
Season 5 Episode 6 - Aired 11/5/1998
After Mark saves a 16-year-old assault victim in a daring rescue, he tries to convince the boy to leave the streets for a shelter. Carter loses his beard when two carpet installers come in covered with glue. Peter consults a deaf physician regarding Reese's hearing condition. Corday is reassigned as Benton's intern. Kerry hears more discouraging news regarding her bid for ER chief. Carter loses his RA job, forcing him to go apartment hunting. He finds one--in Weaver's basement.
Director: David Nutter
Writer: Neal Baer
7.7/10 401 votes#7 - Hazed and Confused
Season 5 Episode 7 - Aired 11/12/1998
Dr. Corday commits a deadly error after being on-call for nearly 36 hours straight. Peter visits Dr. Kotlowitz and receives encouragement regarding a cochlear implant for Reese. Dr. Amanda Lee, a prospective new ER chief, visits. In the wake of a failed pregnancy attempt, Carol lashes out at a mother using abortion as a means of selective birth control. Carter and Lucy feud when Carter accidentally uses her palm computer and finds out what she thinks of him. Mark panics during a paramedic initation.
Director: Jonathan Kaplan
Writer: David Mills
8.3/10 480 votes#8 - The Good Fight
Season 5 Episode 8 - Aired 11/19/1998
Carter and Lucy scramble across Chicago to find a dying girl's father who's a perfect match for her very rare blood type. Benton operates without transfusions to save the little girl's life.
Director: Christopher Chulack
Writer: Jack Orman
7.7/10 409 votes#9 - Good Luck, Ruth Johnson
Season 5 Episode 9 - Aired 12/10/1998
Carter plays tour guide for Ruth Johnson, who was born in the hospital 100 years ago to the day, and her large family. Carol treats a boy who was hit by a car and tells a story of being chased, his friend being shot in the process. Peter observes Kotlowitz install a cochlear implant and decides to wait before scheduling an operation for Reese. Mark dines with Dr. Lee, new ER chief. Dr. Corday proposes radical changes in scheduling at an M&M conference, and later decides to break off her relationship with Benton.
Director: Rod Holcomb
Writer: Lydia Woodward
7.9/10 405 votes#10 - The Miracle Worker
Season 5 Episode 10 - Aired 12/17/1998
Benton's attempts to get away to Carla and Reese on Christmas Eve are continually thwarted by Romano, culminating in Benton forcing the drunken Romano away from a patient. Carter believes he's found a Christmas miracle when a teenage girl with a rare blood type needs an organ donation at the same time a brain-dead patient with the same blood type is in the hospital. After witnessing Dr. Lee rifling through Greene's locker, Jerry becomes convinced that she's stalking Mark.
Director: Lesli Linka Glatter
Writer: Paul Manning
7.9/10 410 votes#11 - Nobody Doesn't Like Amanda Lee
Season 5 Episode 11 - Aired 1/7/1999
Amanda Lee's obsession with Dr. Greene comes to a head when Mark inadvertantly digs up old med school records damaging to her career. Carter tries to save Lucy from Edson's advances. Peter treats Dr. Parks' grandchild, who interprets for her deaf mother and grandmother. Police officer Reggie Moore asks Jeanie out. Kerry receives a call from someone claiming to be her mother. Doug receives a job offer from Portland.
Director: Richard Thorpe
Writer: Linda Gase
7.6/10 377 votes#12 - Double Blind
Season 5 Episode 12 - Aired 1/21/1999
Doug jeopardizes future federal grants for the entire ER when he breaks a double blind study by giving a sample drug to an ailing patient. Doyle lodges a sexual harassment complaint against Romano, hoping Dr. Corday will lend support. Lucy begins her surgery rotation under Benton's tutelage. The two of them treat a man claiming to be 140-years-old. Mark declines to proceed in the NASA program. Carol questions Lynette's intentions when she hosts a women's health clinic for African American women only. Mark goes to bat for Pickman when she inadvertently leaves a severely injured man at an accident scene.
Director: David Chameides
Writer: Carol Flint
7.7/10 389 votes#13 - Choosing Joi
Season 5 Episode 13 - Aired 2/4/1999
Ricky Abbott returns to the ER. Doug forges papers to allow Joi to treat Ricky at home. Corday decides to back out of the Romano sexual harassment investigation after he threatens to expose her relationship with Benton. Romano is later named Acting Chief of the ER. Dr. Greene treats a Nigerian janitor for back pain and impotency. Carol and the nurses watch a bunch of dogs when their owner is hospitalized. Carter diagnoses a med student with Hodgkin's disease. Kerry initiates a search for her biological parents.
Director: Christopher Chulack
Writer: Lydia Woodward
8.3/10 567 votes#14 - The Storm (1)
Season 5 Episode 14 - Aired 2/11/1999
Doug faces possible criminal charges after Ricky Abbott dies when Ross bypasses system lockouts to enable Joi to give Ricky a lethal dosage of dilaudin. Doug is delegated to desk duty, Carol's clinic is shut down for acquiring the P.C.A. machine for Ricky, and Greene and Weaver face future disciplinary action for not reporting Doug's tampering with the double blind study. Carter and Lucy discover a mutual attraction. Benton studies with a sign language instructor.
Director: John Wells
Writer: John Wells
8.5/10 603 votes#15 - The Storm (2)
Season 5 Episode 15 - Aired 2/18/1999
Greene assists paramedics in treating injured children at a school bus accident. En route, Doug and Jeanie survive their own accident. Kerry stops Doug from treating Jeanie...or any other patient. Doug decides to resign and leave Chicago for the Northwest and asks Carol to come with him. She decides against it, but he leaves anyway. Carol steps down from running the clinic so that Anspaugh will keep it open. Jeanie discovers she may have contracted hepatitis. Hospital janitor Mobalage's wife is stabbed.
Director: Christopher Chulack
Writer: John Wells
7.9/10 508 votes#16 - Middle of Nowhere
Season 5 Episode 16 - Aired 2/25/1999
Peter accepts Romano's suggestion and takes a two-week job in Minnesota to earn some extra money. Unfortunately, before he gets a chance to leave, he's transferred to backwoods Mississippi, where the hospital is only a two-room building. Peter battles local racism, delivers a difficult infant while battling the grandfather's concerns that the child might be black, and uses unorthodox methods to save two shrimp boat workers. Meanwhile, back in Chicago, Jeanie's condition worsens.
Director: Jonathan Kaplan
Writer: Carol Flint, Neal Baer
7.6/10 386 votes#17 - Sticks and Stones
Season 5 Episode 17 - Aired 3/25/1999
During a paramedic ride-along, Carter is forced to drive the ambulance while fleeing a riot scene and inadvertently runs over a teenage boy. Later, a paramedic is shot by an angry mob looking for the driver of the ambulance. Carol is despondent following Doug's departure. She later discloses that she's pregnant. Kerry is intrigued by an injured pro wrestler and his relationship with his father. Lucy tangles with an Asian family that requests their matriarch not be told of a cancerous tumor. Jeanie turns down dates with both Dr. Baker and Reggie, telling each she's seeing someone else.
Director: Félix Enríquez Alcalá
Writer: Joe Sachs
7.7/10 375 votes#18 - Point of Origin
Season 5 Episode 18 - Aired 4/8/1999
Greene tries to help Mobalage when he's about to be deported. Kerry tries to save a woman she believes is her birth mother. Hathaway decides to have Doug's child. Benton and Corday clash over an ER fellowship. Carter is in charge for the day, part of a requirement for applying for chief resident.
Director: Christopher Misiano
Writer: Christopher Mack
7.7/10 388 votes#19 - Rites of Spring
Season 5 Episode 19 - Aired 4/29/1999
Romano forces Benton to choose between the trauma and cardiothoracic fellowships. Carol worries that she may have lost her child. Corday and Greene bond on the way to a medical conference. Carter mentors an aspiring teenager. Lucy, on a psychiatry rotation, treats an overmedicated foster child. Jeanie finds her faith while treating a reverend.
Director: Jonathan Kaplan
Writer: David Mills
8.1/10 489 votes#20 - Power
Season 5 Episode 20 - Aired 5/6/1999
The hospital suffers through a series of power outages. Carol's decision to send Doug a fax about her pregnancy is thwarted by the power outages. The staff is on alert after a raped and beaten patient is found in a hallway. Romano begs Corday to stay in trauma. Carter and Roxanne break up. Carter and Lucy treat a pheromone saleswoman.
Director: Laura Innes
Writer: Carol Flint
8.0/10 499 votes#21 - Responsible Parties
Season 5 Episode 21 - Aired 5/13/1999
The ER docs tend to three teenagers who were in an accident on the way to their senior prom. Greene and Carter treat the most severely injured, a boy suffering from third degree burns over 80% of his body. Benton receives the ER trauma fellowship. Carol finally tells Doug about her pregnancy; Kerry also figures it out. Mark and Elizabeth draw closer. Lucy tells Carter about her Ritalin addiction. "FBI agents" bring in a shot stripper.
Director: Christopher Misiano
Writer: Jack Orman
7.9/10 393 votes#22 - Getting to Know You
Season 5 Episode 22 - Aired 5/20/1999
Carol's pregnancy becomes public knowledge as she learns that she's having twins. Lucy has problems trying to go off Ritalin. Peter learns Carla plans to move to Germany. Kerry finds an abandoned youngster and brings him to the ER. Mark and Elizabeth discuss their relationship. Jeanie and Reggie draw closer again.
Director: Jonathan Kaplan
Writer: Lydia Woodward