Judging Amy backdrop
Drama

The Best Episodes of Judging Amy

Every episode of Judging Amy ranked from best to worst. Let's dive into the Best Episodes of Judging Amy!

Binge this in 4d 2h•Peaking at 9.3/10

Judging Amy is an American television drama that was telecast from September 19, 1999, through May 3, 2005, on CBS-TV. This TV series starred Amy Brenneman and Tyne Daly. Its main character is a judge

Airs on
CBS
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons6

All123456

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Fan Favorite
    Click to reveal
    Judging Amy Season 6 Episode 22 - My Name is Amy Gray...
    9.3/10(91 votes)

    S6:E22

    Amy says her final goodbyes to Graciela. Maxine realizes that she made a mistake in pushing Ignacio away and tries to reach out to him but Ignacio rebuffs her because he doesn't want to be her yo-yo, jerked around on Maxine's whims. Bruce is still absent on Amy's last day in the courtroom. Holbrook tries to raise awareness about the bill before Congress that will effectively kill the juvenille justice system. Donna is amazed that Amy refuses to support the cause and brings several of the kids whose lives Amy has changed during her time on the bench in an effort to change her mind. Amy, frustrated by her limitations as a judge, runs into Marty Levine, who again tries to convince her to give the speech in Washington and run for Senate. Amy runs the idea by Lauren who at first refuses to give a straight answer but later supports her mom when Maxine attacks the decision. That same night, Maxine must rush to save a young girl from being pimped out by her prostitute mother. Amy receive

    Director:Helen Shaver
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 6 - Roses and Truth
    8.7/10(38 votes)

    S4:E6

    Amy must decide if a student raped his teacher or was seduced by her; Kyle is unhappy about his nonmedical duties at St. Michael's; Maxine tries to locate the mother of an abandoned newborn; after Jason menaces Amy while she's driving Lauren and Eric home, Bruce suggests getting a restraining order; fearing the worst about her health, Gillian gets the diagnosis she's dreamed of for years.

    Director:Kevin Dowling
    Writer:Lyla Oliver

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 8 - A Pretty Good Day
    8.6/10(41 votes)

    S4:E8

    Amy's ruling in the case of a teenager who called in a bomb scare to avoid a test is complicated by the arrival of an I.N.S. agent who's ready to deport the boy to Afghanistan, and almost certain death, if he's found guilty; Eric saves Lauren from being kidnapped by Jason; Gillian's raging hormones leave Peter exhausted as she goes into overdrive about the plans for Maxine's wedding; Kimberly blackmails Sean into getting her job back in exchange for helping Maxine find an endangered teenager who's aged out of the system; Kyle defies hospital protocol to give a dying woman her last wish; Eric ends Jason's stalking with tragic finality.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 13 - The Best Interests of the Child
    8.6/10(38 votes)

    S4:E13

    Amy and Michael face off in court, and the resolution of their custody battle reveals yet another unsavory aspect of Michael's character; Kyle counsels a mother who struggles over a DNR order for her critically ill son; after Amy and Sean each confront her about Eric, Maxine visits him in jail to hear his story of the night Jason died.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. Judging Amy Season 5 Episode 7 - Kilt Trip
    8.6/10(47 votes)

    S5:E7

    Forced to substitute for an ailing colleague just two days before her wedding, Amy presides over a felony murder case involving a 14 year old boy and makes a controversial decision to overturn the jury's verdict; Stu's groomsmen are less than thrilled when they realize that they'll be wearing kilts instead of tuxes at the wedding; Kyle hatches a plan to surprise the rest of the family with Vincent's presence at the wedding, and gets a surprise himself when he walks in on Vincent and Heather making out; Amy forgets to get a sub as the judge on call, and ends up signing one warrant after another for David; Maxine's search for an apartment goes poorly, and the attempts of a co-worker and Stu's mother to be helpful only make things worse; Amy's pre-wedding jitters turn into a full scale panic attack as the ceremony begins; realizing that she doesn't want to marry Stu, she calls the wedding off; later that evening, Vincent tells Amy that Carole has left him for her oncologist.

    Director:Alan Myerson
    Writer:Karen Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. Judging Amy Season 1 Episode 7 - An Impartial Bias
    8.5/10(76 votes)

    S1:E7

    Maxine fights to keep a deaf boy in the care of his teenage brother after they are orphaned; Bruce disagrees with Amy's decision in an interracial adoption case; Vincent gets a job teaching writing; Donna seeks Amy's assistance in getting a conjugal visit with Oscar; Vincent learns something surprising about his father.

    Director:James Hayman
    Writer:David W. Zucker

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 WORST Episodes of Judging Amy

    READ
  7. Judging Amy Season 3 Episode 21 - Tidal Wave
    8.5/10(37 votes)

    S3:E21

    Maxine works more tirelessly than ever on the Pamela Taylor investigation as she assists an attorney in finding other abused teens who are willing to join in the Taylors' class action suit against Buckley Hills; when a social worker in a child abuse case appears in her courtroom with an attitude, and without any of the periodic reports she was ordered to file with the court, Amy cites her for contempt and has her arrested when she discovers that the social worker is unaware of the child's present whereabouts; later that evening at the dinner table, Maxine takes vociferous objection to Amy's ruling and accuses her of displacing her fears and frustration about Maxine's health onto a good social worker who is overworked and overwhelmed; realizing that her mother is right, Amy has the social worker released from jail; when Donna discovers how much Kyle regrets not completing his medical training, she prods him into resuming his studies; Amy presides at the sentencing hearing for two young

    Director:Kevin Dowling
    Writer:Lyla Oliver

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 1 - Lost in the System
    8.5/10(50 votes)

    S4:E1

    Amy and Michael agree to work out Lauren's custody with a mediator; Maxine and Kimberly clash over a child lost in the system; Jared returns from China to get an answer from Maxine; Lauren fears that their apartment is haunted and Amy begins to agree with her; appearing before Amy in court as the caseworker for a teenaged mother, Maxine gives an impassioned plea which provides Amy with food for thought about not only the girl, but Amy's relationships with Maxine and Lauren; Bruce runs into Amy and spurns her offer of friendship, but later relents most emphatically.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Barbara Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  9. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 7 - Damage Control
    8.5/10(40 votes)

    S4:E7

    Amy hears the case of a young boy charged with obstruction of justice for not revealing the name of the man who took pornographic pictures of him; Maxine contends with a woman who allows her abusive husband to violate a restraining order; Peter and Charles negotiate a prenuptial agreement for their parents; Jason Lobdel eludes Amy's police protection as he continues to stalk her; everyone walks on eggshells as Gillian suffers through ugly hormonal mood swings; Jared gives Maxine the diner; Amy's plan to censure an attorney backfires.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  10. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 14 - Wild Card
    8.5/10(38 votes)

    S4:E14

    Maxine and Sean battle a sleazy attorney with a penchant for blackmail when they attempt to remove a child from her negligent parents; Amy presides over the case of a deadbeat dad who is willing to go to extreme measures to avoid paying child support when he learns that his son's paternity may be at issue; Maxine is ""filled with existential dread"" at the prospect of the wedding ceremony Gillian is planning for her; Kyle experiences a sleepless night discovering why the parents of a handicapped man who appears to be healthy insist that he be hospitalized overnight.

    Director:Alan Myerson
    Writer:Matt Witten

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  11. Judging Amy Season 3 Episode 8 - Rights of Passage
    8.4/10(40 votes)

    S3:E8

    Donna stumbles as she subs for Bruce as Amy's C.S.O. while he attempts to convince the probation officer of a teenager that Amy assigned to a diversionary program to keep the boy out of prison after a fight with members of his former gang; Maxine's nephew Kyle comes back into the family fold, much to Amy's displeasure; Amy must decide whether to commit a young boy who stole a rifle and slaughtered a yak as part of a coming-of-age ritual to a locked psychiatric facility, or turn him over to the sentencing circle of his Native American tribe; Kyle's medical knowledge helps Maxine solve the mystery of why five boys from an exemplary foster home have severe abrasions on their arms.

    Director:Andrew Robinson
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  12. Judging Amy Season 3 Episode 20 - The Bottle Show
    8.4/10(40 votes)

    S3:E20

    Maxine is saddened when Jared fails to call her upon his return from China, so Sean arranges a casino night fund raiser to cheer her up; a born-again teenager charges her mother with parental neglect for working as a stripper, and Amy must decide whether to place the girl in foster care; Donna confronts Kyle after she finds a syringe and morphine in his room drawers and is relieved to hear that he keeps it as a reminder that he is capable of making the choice to stay clean every day; after his daughter tells him about her ill-timed encounter with Bruce, David Solomon files a complaint against Andrea, who immediately ends her relationship with Bruce for fear of losing custody; responding to a message from Bruce attempting to explain the situation, Solomon shows up at the courthouse and threatens, taunts and insults Bruce, who is arrested and jailed after he knocks Solomon to the ground with a punch.

    Director:Andrew Robinson
    Writer:Barry O'Brien

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  13. Judging Amy Season 3 Episode 23 - Nobody Expects the Spanish Inquisition
    8.4/10(38 votes)

    S3:E23

    Amy, Maxine and Lauren have trouble adjusting to their new living arrangements; Vincent returns for a visit to smooth over the waters between his mother and sister and persuade them to live together again; after Lauren tearfully calls Michael about the move, he suggests to Amy that Lauren come to live with him; Amy presides over a custody dispute involving a father who refuses to take a paternity test; Donna dates one of Amy's law school classmates; Amy ends her relationship with Barry.

    Director:Elodie Keene
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  14. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 9 - Boys to Men
    8.4/10(44 votes)

    S4:E9

    Maxine and Jared move up their wedding date, to the consternation of their children; Peter's plans for a classy bachelor party go awry, but the men manage to have a good time at a less highbrow establishment as they convince a greatly under-the-influence Bruce to call Zola and ask her for a date; Maxine's hen party is much more sedate, but Maxine manages to work out an escape plan nonetheless; Amy presides over a hearing to determine if four teenage boys accused of drugging and raping a teenage girl should be tried as adults; after Charles announces that he's quit his job, Jared is forced to return to China and reschedule the wedding, and Amy lets Charles know that it's not in his best interest to interfere with Maxine's happiness; Maxine's efforts to keep Eric's case in juvenile court are successful.

    Director:Helen Shaver
    Writer:Barbara Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  15. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 24 - Shock and Awe
    8.4/10(44 votes)

    S4:E24

    A stressed out public defender goes ballistic in Amy's courtroom; Maxine tries to figure out why a woman who lost her son wants to give up her foster child; Kyle tells Lily how he feels, but it doesn't go as he hoped; Amy is confused about whether or not Stu actually proposed marriage; Gillian goes into labor with unexpected and seemingly tragic results.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  16. Judging Amy Season 5 Episode 14 - Roadhouse Blues
    8.4/10(37 votes)

    S5:E14

    Despite their protests, Maxine and Amy fail to convince anyone that that dinners out with Ignacio and David don't constitute dating; Amy is asked to decide if a man in the Witness Protection Program can regain custody of his eleven year old son after the boy's mother dies; Lauren and Victor are unhappy when they discover that their parents are dating; Maxine races against time to prevent the participants in a suicide pact at a local high school from carrying out their plans; Shelby's band gets a gig at a local bar, and Peter's invitation to his mother and sister to hear him play provides the opportunity for the relationships between Amy and David, Maxine and Ignacio, and Peter and Shelby to grow and intensify on the dance floor and stage.

    Director:Helen Shaver
    Writer:Barry O'Brien

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  17. Judging Amy Season 1 Episode 11 - Presumed Innocent
    8.3/10(51 votes)

    S1:E11

    Amy takes it personally when Stuart appeals her decision to overturn the jury's verdict; Maxine arrives at a creative solution in placing an extremely gifted teenager who chronically runs away from his foster placements; Donna becomes Vincent's new roommate; Amy must decide whether to remove a child from the care of a mother suspected of suffering from Munchausen by Proxy syndrome; after her verdict is upheld, Stuart asks Amy out on a date, and she royally disses him as she turns him down flat.

    Director:James Hayman
    Writer:Natalie Chaidez

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  18. Judging Amy Season 1 Episode 13 - Zero to Sixty
    8.3/10(45 votes)

    S1:E13

    Michael's insistence upon joint custody of Lauren after Amy requests an increase in child support payments dooms the divorce mediation process, and they each retain high-powered and aggressive attorneys; Maxine wants nothing to do with any celebration of her 60th birthday; Amy must decide whether a college senior should be charged as an adult for a fatal hit and run accident that occured when he was fifteen; Michael's attempt to win Vincent over to his side in the custody battle ends badly; Amy hears a father's petition which contests the divorce agreement requiring him to pay for his daughter's college education; Maxine deals with combative divorced parents who can't seem to manage a peaceful exchange of their three small children.

    Director:Anita W. Addison
    Writer:David Adam Silverman

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  19. Judging Amy Season 2 Episode 5 - Unnecessary Roughness
    8.3/10(43 votes)

    S2:E5

    Amy seeks to have Lauren qualified as a ""gifted"" student; Maxine agrees to take a anger management class after going too far in insulting a coworker and accosting the boy who vandalized the Gray home; Amy dates a detective who's ""out of her league""; Vincent agrees to be Donna's birthing partner; Amy presides at the sentencing hearing for a teenager who intentionally maimed a rival player during a hockey game.

    Director:David Platt
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  20. Judging Amy Season 2 Episode 20 - Grounded
    8.3/10(42 votes)

    S2:E20

    Felled by the flu, Amy collapses in court, but not before presiding over a custody hearing for a cow; long-buried feelings erupt between Gillian and Peter when Evie offers to return Ned; Amy's caseload has more of an effect on her temporary replacement than he expected; after Sean grounds her to desk duty for taking wannabee gangbangers on an unauthorized field trip to the local I.C.U. which draws outcries from their parents, Maxine decides not to ask him for a few days off to accompany Jared on a business trip to China; Carole accepts a job offer in San Francisco and asks Vincent to come with her; Sean supports Maxine when Jared's plane is reported missing; the Gray family rejoices when both Ned and Jared are returned to them safely.

    Director:James Hayman
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  21. Judging Amy Season 3 Episode 18 - The Justice League of America
    8.3/10(40 votes)

    S3:E18

    When a teenager whom neither parent wanted and Amy placed in a locked facility escapes and comes into D.C.F. with bruises she says were caused by abuse at the facility, Maxine's decision to have her returned to the facility leads to tragedy; Amy attends the tenth reunion of her Harvard Law School class and is disheartened by how petty, mean-spirited, and sleazy her former law school best friends have become, until Barry shows up unexpectedly as her white knight and saves the day; Michael makes it obvious that he is still attracted to Amy, and expresses regret over their divorce and his marriage to Leisha; Maxine scoffs when Sean has all the files computerized, but changes her tune when he swiftly downloads information which helps them identify and locate a suicidal teenager.

    Director:Martha Mitchell
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  22. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 2 - Thursday's Child
    8.3/10(46 votes)

    S4:E2

    Amy's discovers that the man the police have in custody may not be her stalker after all; Maxine refuses to give up on a client who may be the victim of police brutality; after Bruce denies having romantic feelings for Amy and they agree that confusion and alcohol led to their embrace, they decide to be friends who don't kiss; Kyle applies for a residency and is confronted by his sponsor for not working his program; a persistent attorney paves the way for Bruce to regain his court position; Amy must decide if a retarded teenager is competent to make her own reproductive choices.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  23. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 10 - People of the Lie
    8.3/10(41 votes)

    S4:E10

    Amy must decide if a little girl in the middle of a bitter custody dispute is being molested by her father; doing research for a paper, Donna shadows Maxine during a day in which she deals with the neglected children of a severely depressed mother who refuses treatment; Kyle receives an unwelcome visit from his mother and sister; after employing a private investigator to follow Amy for over a year, Michael sues for full custody of Lauren; the decorator that Amy hires to redo the kitchen disparages Maxine's taste.

    Director:Andrew Robinson
    Writer:Karen Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  24. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 16 - Sixteen Going on Seventeen
    8.3/10(38 votes)

    S4:E16

    Stuart Collins returns from Sri Lanka reincarnated as a criminal defense attorney eager to take on Eric's case and renew his romance with Amy; Peter and Gillian hear unsettling news about the potential health of their unborn child; Maxine and Sean work together to create the best possible placement for a young Sudanese refugee; a father petitions Amy for legal custody of his 14 year old daughter after her mother allows her to drop out of school and pursue a full-time career as a pop star with an over-sexualized and age-inappropriate image.

    Director:Fred Gerber
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  25. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 17 - Judging Eric
    8.3/10(55 votes)

    S4:E17

    Amy, Bruce, Lauren, Sean and Maxine rally around Eric as he goes on trial before an eccentric but wise judge; Maxine takes issue with Eric on a question of ethics about his testimony which colors her reaction to his verdict; after Zola breaks up with her boyfriend, she unsuccessfully resists Bruce's efforts to woo her; Kyle is faced with a medical and ethical dilemma when his patient's routine problem takes an inexplicable and tragic turn; Eric tells Maxine about a new person in his life; Heather and Kyle grow closer.

    Director:Donna Deitch
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Best Episodes Summary

"My Name is Amy Gray..." is the best rated episode of "Judging Amy". It scored 9.3/10 based on 91 votes. Directed by Helen Shaver and written by Unknown, it aired on 5/3/2005. This episode scored 0.6 points higher than the second highest rated, "Roses and Truth".