Judging Amy backdrop
Drama

The Best Episodes of Judging Amy Season 4

Every episode of Judging Amy Season 4 ranked from best to worst. Discover the Best Episodes of Judging Amy Season 4!

Binge this in 17h 12m•Peaking at 8.6/10

Judging Amy is an American television drama that was telecast from September 19, 1999, through May 3, 2005, on CBS-TV. This TV series starred Amy Brenneman and Tyne Daly. Its main character is a judge

Airs on
CBS
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons6

All123456

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Fan Favorite
    Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 1 - Lost in the System
    8.5/10(49 votes)

    #1 - Lost in the System

    S4:E1

    Amy and Michael agree to work out Lauren's custody with a mediator; Maxine and Kimberly clash over a child lost in the system; Jared returns from China to get an answer from Maxine; Lauren fears that their apartment is haunted and Amy begins to agree with her; appearing before Amy in court as the caseworker for a teenaged mother, Maxine gives an impassioned plea which provides Amy with food for thought about not only the girl, but Amy's relationships with Maxine and Lauren; Bruce runs into Amy and spurns her offer of friendship, but later relents most emphatically.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Barbara Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 2 - Thursday's Child
    8.2/10(47 votes)

    #2 - Thursday's Child

    S4:E2

    Amy's discovers that the man the police have in custody may not be her stalker after all; Maxine refuses to give up on a client who may be the victim of police brutality; after Bruce denies having romantic feelings for Amy and they agree that confusion and alcohol led to their embrace, they decide to be friends who don't kiss; Kyle applies for a residency and is confronted by his sponsor for not working his program; a persistent attorney paves the way for Bruce to regain his court position; Amy must decide if a retarded teenager is competent to make her own reproductive choices.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 3 - Every Stranger's Face I See
    7.7/10(39 votes)

    #3 - Every Stranger's Face I See

    S4:E3

    As Amy decides the fate of a ten year old boy who was kidnapped by his adoptive parents when they lost custody to his birth mother, she finds an answer to some of her own family's pressing concerns; Bruce is back at work as Amy's C.S.O. and is completing his community service at a soup kitchen; Amy gets the silent treatment from Lauren when she won't let her become a cheerleader, but both sides are forced to relent when Gillian unwittingly spills the beans about her own and Amy's cheerleading pasts; Maxine's refusal to sell her house to buyers she doesn't like leaves Peter feeling angry and unappreciated, so she hatches a plan that heals both him and a badly abused client; at the behest of his sponsor, Kyle applies to every residency program in the area, and Amy agrees to write him a letter of recommendation; Maxine finally finds the perfect buyer for her house.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 4 - The Frozen Zone
    8.0/10(35 votes)

    #4 - The Frozen Zone

    S4:E4

    Amy presides over the custody hearing of a boy whose mother died in the collapse of the World Trade Center; an old friend offers Kyle a job with a pharmaceutical company, and Maxine counteroffers with the job of heading the Center; Amy relandscapes her new home and accidently throws out Ethel, the antique heirloom rosebush Maxine's grandmother brought over from Ireland in 1889; after initially spurning her offer, Bruce agrees to speak at Zola's press conference for convicted felons; and Maxine helps Sean over some rough spots as Eric's foster father.

    Director:Alan Myerson
    Writer:Karen Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 5 - Cause For Alarm
    7.9/10(34 votes)

    #5 - Cause For Alarm

    S4:E5

    Amy must decide whether a teenager is responsible for the death of an infant she was babysitting; Maxine investigates an abuse case at the home of a disabled veteran and his adopted granddaughter; Kyle is torn between keeping his lucrative job as a pharmaceutical rep or accepting a residency at a low-ranked hospital; Amy has an alarm system installed in the house as her stalker escalates his harassment; Maxine and Peter are at odds after Maxine attributes Peter's promotion within the ranks of a Revolutionary War reenactment group to the publicity surrounding her engagement to Jared.

    Director:Elodie Keene
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 6 - Roses and Truth
    8.6/10(38 votes)

    #6 - Roses and Truth

    S4:E6

    Amy must decide if a student raped his teacher or was seduced by her; Kyle is unhappy about his nonmedical duties at St. Michael's; Maxine tries to locate the mother of an abandoned newborn; after Jason menaces Amy while she's driving Lauren and Eric home, Bruce suggests getting a restraining order; fearing the worst about her health, Gillian gets the diagnosis she's dreamed of for years.

    Director:Kevin Dowling
    Writer:Lyla Oliver

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 BEST Episodes of Judging Amy

    READ
  7. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 7 - Damage Control
    8.4/10(40 votes)

    #7 - Damage Control

    S4:E7

    Amy hears the case of a young boy charged with obstruction of justice for not revealing the name of the man who took pornographic pictures of him; Maxine contends with a woman who allows her abusive husband to violate a restraining order; Peter and Charles negotiate a prenuptial agreement for their parents; Jason Lobdel eludes Amy's police protection as he continues to stalk her; everyone walks on eggshells as Gillian suffers through ugly hormonal mood swings; Jared gives Maxine the diner; Amy's plan to censure an attorney backfires.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 8 - A Pretty Good Day
    8.5/10(41 votes)

    #8 - A Pretty Good Day

    S4:E8

    Amy's ruling in the case of a teenager who called in a bomb scare to avoid a test is complicated by the arrival of an I.N.S. agent who's ready to deport the boy to Afghanistan, and almost certain death, if he's found guilty; Eric saves Lauren from being kidnapped by Jason; Gillian's raging hormones leave Peter exhausted as she goes into overdrive about the plans for Maxine's wedding; Kimberly blackmails Sean into getting her job back in exchange for helping Maxine find an endangered teenager who's aged out of the system; Kyle defies hospital protocol to give a dying woman her last wish; Eric ends Jason's stalking with tragic finality.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  9. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 9 - Boys to Men
    8.3/10(44 votes)

    #9 - Boys to Men

    S4:E9

    Maxine and Jared move up their wedding date, to the consternation of their children; Peter's plans for a classy bachelor party go awry, but the men manage to have a good time at a less highbrow establishment as they convince a greatly under-the-influence Bruce to call Zola and ask her for a date; Maxine's hen party is much more sedate, but Maxine manages to work out an escape plan nonetheless; Amy presides over a hearing to determine if four teenage boys accused of drugging and raping a teenage girl should be tried as adults; after Charles announces that he's quit his job, Jared is forced to return to China and reschedule the wedding, and Amy lets Charles know that it's not in his best interest to interfere with Maxine's happiness; Maxine's efforts to keep Eric's case in juvenile court are successful.

    Director:Helen Shaver
    Writer:Barbara Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  10. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 10 - People of the Lie
    8.3/10(42 votes)

    #10 - People of the Lie

    S4:E10

    Amy must decide if a little girl in the middle of a bitter custody dispute is being molested by her father; doing research for a paper, Donna shadows Maxine during a day in which she deals with the neglected children of a severely depressed mother who refuses treatment; Kyle receives an unwelcome visit from his mother and sister; after employing a private investigator to follow Amy for over a year, Michael sues for full custody of Lauren; the decorator that Amy hires to redo the kitchen disparages Maxine's taste.

    Director:Andrew Robinson
    Writer:Karen Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  11. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 11 - Lost and Found
    8.0/10(38 votes)

    #11 - Lost and Found

    S4:E11

    Maxine incurs the wrath of the mothers in Lauren's carpool; Amy fears her parenting skills will be called into question when a family-relations officer visits her home as part of Michael's custody suit; Kyle and Lily try to locate a man Lily misdiagnosed and prematurely released from the hospital; Maxine feels Sean's new relationship with a new foster mother is inappropriate; substituting in probate court, Amy rules on whether a mother can have her son declared legally dead despite the father's hope that the boy, who disappeared four years earlier, is still alive.

    Director:James Hayman
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  12. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 12 - Ye Olde Freedom Inn
    8.1/10(37 votes)

    #12 - Ye Olde Freedom Inn

    S4:E12

    After Amy accidently sets on fire the homework that Lauren has spent hours painstakingly hand-calligraphing, she agrees to make it up to her by spending the weekend role-playing at an 18th century inn and inviting Maxine to join them. The going is rougher than she anticipated when they are assigned the roles of kitchen servants. Over a late night fireside heart-to-heart chat, Maxine and Amy share their dislike of change and inability to reconcile conflicting emotions about their place in the world. Bruce pursues Zola after meeting, and being completely unimpressed by, her boyfriend. Kyle treats a 14 year old girl who delivered a baby in a high school bathroom, and cannot get through to the girl's mother, who is unwilling to accept her responsibilites as a parent. Gillian gets an unexpected job offer after spending a long day waiting to interview a new pediatrician. Amy must revoke a custody order after a father reverts to his former abusive ways.

    Director:Kevin Dowling
    Writer:Lyla Oliver

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  13. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 13 - The Best Interests of the Child
    8.4/10(38 votes)

    #13 - The Best Interests of the Child

    S4:E13

    Amy and Michael face off in court, and the resolution of their custody battle reveals yet another unsavory aspect of Michael's character; Kyle counsels a mother who struggles over a DNR order for her critically ill son; after Amy and Sean each confront her about Eric, Maxine visits him in jail to hear his story of the night Jason died.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  14. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 14 - Wild Card
    8.4/10(38 votes)

    #14 - Wild Card

    S4:E14

    Maxine and Sean battle a sleazy attorney with a penchant for blackmail when they attempt to remove a child from her negligent parents; Amy presides over the case of a deadbeat dad who is willing to go to extreme measures to avoid paying child support when he learns that his son's paternity may be at issue; Maxine is ""filled with existential dread"" at the prospect of the wedding ceremony Gillian is planning for her; Kyle experiences a sleepless night discovering why the parents of a handicapped man who appears to be healthy insist that he be hospitalized overnight.

    Director:Alan Myerson
    Writer:Matt Witten

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  15. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 15 - Maxine, Interrupted
    8.1/10(48 votes)

    #15 - Maxine, Interrupted

    S4:E15

    Maxine's reunion with Sally Godwin, her college classmate and former co-worker in the social work trenches, comes under strain after the up-and-coming politician reveals that she's back in town to evaluate Maxine's performance, and they clash over the case of a child with a sexually transmitted disease; a father testifies on behalf of his teenage daughter who appears before Amy for conspiring in his attempted murder; Bruce utilizes Donna's assistance in a creative approach to mediating the divorce of an elderly couple fighting over custody of their pet parrot.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Karen Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  16. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 16 - Sixteen Going on Seventeen
    8.2/10(39 votes)

    #16 - Sixteen Going on Seventeen

    S4:E16

    Stuart Collins returns from Sri Lanka reincarnated as a criminal defense attorney eager to take on Eric's case and renew his romance with Amy; Peter and Gillian hear unsettling news about the potential health of their unborn child; Maxine and Sean work together to create the best possible placement for a young Sudanese refugee; a father petitions Amy for legal custody of his 14 year old daughter after her mother allows her to drop out of school and pursue a full-time career as a pop star with an over-sexualized and age-inappropriate image.

    Director:Fred Gerber
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  17. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 17 - Judging Eric
    8.2/10(55 votes)

    #17 - Judging Eric

    S4:E17

    Amy, Bruce, Lauren, Sean and Maxine rally around Eric as he goes on trial before an eccentric but wise judge; Maxine takes issue with Eric on a question of ethics about his testimony which colors her reaction to his verdict; after Zola breaks up with her boyfriend, she unsuccessfully resists Bruce's efforts to woo her; Kyle is faced with a medical and ethical dilemma when his patient's routine problem takes an inexplicable and tragic turn; Eric tells Maxine about a new person in his life; Heather and Kyle grow closer.

    Director:Donna Deitch
    Writer:Hart Hanson

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  18. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 18 - Looking For Quarters
    7.0/10(39 votes)

    #18 - Looking For Quarters

    S4:E18

    Maxine unwittingly provides Amy with the information she needs to decide whether promoters are responsible for the death of a teenager who died from an ecstasy overdose during one of their raves; Maxine and Sean join forces to persuade a couple to take back their former foster child after she's released from work camp; Amy and Maxine disagree about Amy's being overprotective of Lauren; Sean lets Maxine know he's angry about her judgemental attitude toward Eric; after conferring with Martin, Kyle decides to pursue a romance with Heather; Kyle goes off the wagon when he and Heather throw a party to celebrate their successful evaluations; after Lily sees them kissing at the party, she decides not to reveal that a random drug test is being conducted the next day, and Heather is fired; Bruce distances himself from Amy in an effort to convince Zola that there's nothing going on between them.

    Director:James Hayman
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  19. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 19 - Just Say Oops
    7.9/10(38 votes)

    #19 - Just Say Oops

    S4:E19

    Maxine tempers her frustrations over her daughter-in-law's outlandish plans for the Gray-Duff nuptuals after Peter tells his mother about Gillian's refusal to face their new baby's condition; Stu's plans for a romantic dinner to celebrate the rekindling of his relationship with Amy are derailed by an obnoxious couple at the next table; Kyle discovers why Lily has been treating him so poorly; after Amy hears the case of a pro-cannabis couple threatened with losing custody of their son after he brings a joint to school, she has a talk with Lauren about drugs; Maxine investigates when a man asserts that his ex-wife has been cheating on the drug tests required as a condition of her retaining custody of their daughter; Amy has conflicting emotions after she reads the Judge Gray tribute page on Donna's blog.

    Director:Helen Shaver
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  20. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 20 - Requiem
    7.7/10(41 votes)

    #20 - Requiem

    S4:E20

    Stu convinces a reluctant Amy to go on an overnight camping trip which ends up bringing them closer together; after planning to wed Jared secretly on the weekend, Maxine is devastated when he has a sudden, fatal heart attack in China and lashes out in her grief to everyone around her, including a rebellious teenaged client; tensions run high in the Gray household when Maxine refuses to allow anyone to comfort her, and Peter and Charles bicker over the funeral arrangements as a way of handling their sorrow; Maxine gathers family and friends at the diner for a moving memorial service.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Barbara Hall

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  21. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 21 - Picture of Perfect
    7.9/10(37 votes)

    #21 - Picture of Perfect

    S4:E21

    Maxine's first day back on the job finds her removing a boy from the custody of his mother, who was one of Maxine's clients for a short time eight years earlier; although Amy is worried about Maxine's bottling up her grief, she becomes unsettled when Kyle tells her that Maxine has been talking to Charles instead of her own children; Kyle does an end-run around Lily to get an indigent patient the reconstructive surgery she desperately needs after an accident; Amy hears the custody case of a teenager whose divorced parents disagree about sending her to a school for overweight children.

    Director:Kenneth Zunder
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  22. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 22 - CSO: Hartford
    8.2/10(37 votes)

    #22 - CSO: Hartford

    S4:E22

    On ""Take Your Daughter to Work Day"", Lauren learns how lucky she is when she spends the afternoon with Maxine, and Rebecca becomes seriously injured after she falls during a seizure; Kyle continues to drink; Stu reassures Amy that she's a permanent part of his life after she fails to make a fabulous first impression during lunch with his opinionated mother; Bruce struggles to get a boy discharged from probation; after begging Lily to rehire Heather, Kyle is shocked when she refuses to return; Heather and Zola let the men in their lives know that they've got romance on their minds.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Lyla Oliver

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  23. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 23 - Marry, Marry Quite Contrary
    7.8/10(40 votes)

    #23 - Marry, Marry Quite Contrary

    S4:E23

    Amy must decide if it's in a teenager's best interest to get married; Bruce investigates when he suspects that a teenager's probation violation isn't as innocent as his parole officer claims; Amy struggles with telling Lauren that she's dating Stu; after worrying about Gillian's insistence that the baby's fine, and a girl, Peter decides to let her hold on to her beliefs when he discovers that they're having a boy; Lily considers accepting a job offer in New York; Michael confesses to Amy that he was to blame for their divorce.

    Director:Alan Myerson
    Writer:James Stanley

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  24. Judging Amy Season 4 Episode 24 - Shock and Awe
    8.4/10(44 votes)

    #24 - Shock and Awe

    S4:E24

    A stressed out public defender goes ballistic in Amy's courtroom; Maxine tries to figure out why a woman who lost her son wants to give up her foster child; Kyle tells Lily how he feels, but it doesn't go as he hoped; Amy is confused about whether or not Stu actually proposed marriage; Gillian goes into labor with unexpected and seemingly tragic results.

    Director:James Frawley
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Season 4 Ratings Summary

"Lost in the System" is the best rated episode of "Judging Amy" season 4. It scored 8.5/10 based on 49 votes. Directed by James Frawley and written by Barbara Hall, it aired on 10/1/2002. This episode is rated 0.3 points higher than the second-best, "Thursday's Child".