Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries backdrop
Mystery

The Best Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Every episode of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries ranked from best to worst. Let's dive into the Best Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries!

Binge this in 44m•Peaking at 8.2/10

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

Airs on
UP TV
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons1

All1

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Fan Favorite
    Click to reveal
    Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 6 - Stitch in Time
    8.2/10(25 votes)

    S1:E6

    A mysterious quilt leads Cheryl to a buried secret—and a family ready to heal.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 8 - When There’s a Will
    8.1/10(20 votes)

    S1:E8

    A missing deed, county corruption, and a race against time threaten Levi’s land and future.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 3 - O Little Town of Sugarcreek
    7.7/10(29 votes)

    S1:E3

    Christmas thefts and a returned ex force Cheryl to protect an innocent friend and her heart.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 4 - Off the Beaten Path
    7.5/10(25 votes)

    S1:E4

    A vanished bus, fake FBI agents, and hidden feelings test Cheryl’s courage—and her heart.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 7 - Mason Jar Mayhem
    7.5/10(20 votes)

    S1:E7

    Hidden wartime treasures spark a mystery Cheryl must solve before history is lost again.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 2 - A Season of Secrets
    7.4/10(31 votes)

    S1:E2

    A vanished Amish boy, secret texts, and buried truths pull Cheryl into Sugarcreek’s most personal mystery.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 WORST Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

    READ
  7. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 5 - Simply Vanished
    7.4/10(24 votes)

    S1:E5

    A hidden chute leads Cheryl to a decades-old disappearance—and a birthday she’ll never forget.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 1 - The Buggy Before the Horse
    7.3/10(41 votes)

    S1:E1

    A hidden intruder tests faith and compassion as Cheryl races to protect Sugarcreek before Thanksgiving.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Best Episodes Summary

"Stitch in Time" is the best rated episode of "Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries". It scored 8.2/10 based on 25 votes. Directed by Unknown and written by Unknown, it aired on 5/28/2026. This episode scored 0.1 points higher than the second highest rated, "When There’s a Will".