Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries backdrop
Mystery

The Best Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1

Every episode of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 ranked from best to worst. Discover the Best Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1!

Binge this in 44m•Peaking at 8.2/10

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

Airs on
UP TV
BestEpisodes
WorstEpisodes
BestSeasons
AllEpisodes

Seasons1

All1

Episode Rankings

  1. #1 Fan Favorite
    Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 6 - Stitch in Time
    8.2/10(25 votes)

    S1:E6

    A mysterious quilt leads Cheryl to a buried secret—and a family ready to heal.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  2. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 8 - When There’s a Will
    8.1/10(20 votes)

    S1:E8

    A missing deed, county corruption, and a race against time threaten Levi’s land and future.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  3. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 3 - O Little Town of Sugarcreek
    7.7/10(29 votes)

    S1:E3

    Christmas thefts and a returned ex force Cheryl to protect an innocent friend and her heart.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  4. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 4 - Off the Beaten Path
    7.5/10(25 votes)

    S1:E4

    A vanished bus, fake FBI agents, and hidden feelings test Cheryl’s courage—and her heart.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  5. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 7 - Mason Jar Mayhem
    7.5/10(20 votes)

    S1:E7

    Hidden wartime treasures spark a mystery Cheryl must solve before history is lost again.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  6. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 2 - A Season of Secrets
    7.4/10(31 votes)

    S1:E2

    A vanished Amish boy, secret texts, and buried truths pull Cheryl into Sugarcreek’s most personal mystery.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

    7. Trending NowTRENDING NOW

    The 20 BEST Episodes of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

    READ
  7. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 5 - Simply Vanished
    7.4/10(24 votes)

    S1:E5

    A hidden chute leads Cheryl to a decades-old disappearance—and a birthday she’ll never forget.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

  8. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Season 1 Episode 1 - The Buggy Before the Horse
    7.3/10(41 votes)

    S1:E1

    A hidden intruder tests faith and compassion as Cheryl races to protect Sugarcreek before Thanksgiving.

    Director:Unknown
    Writer:Unknown

    Be the first to start the conversation for this episode

Season 1 Ratings Summary

"Stitch in Time" is the best rated episode of "Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries" season 1. It scored 8.2/10 based on 25 votes. Directed by Unknown and written by Unknown, it aired on 5/28/2026. This episode is rated 0.1 points higher than the second-best, "When There’s a Will".