Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries S1E5 — Simply Vanished

7.4

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries•Season 1•Episode 5

Simply Vanished

7.4/10 · 24 votesMay 21, 2026

Ranked #7 of 8 in Season 1•−0.2 vs season avg

Discussion

A hidden chute leads Cheryl to a decades-old disappearance—and a birthday she’ll never forget.

Previous episodeE4 · Off the Beaten Path Next episodeE6 · Stitch in Time

Seasons1

All 1

Season 1 Episodes8

E1 7.3

The Buggy Before the Horse

E2 7.4

A Season of Secrets

E3 7.7

O Little Town of Sugarcreek

Off the Beaten Path

Simply Vanished

Stitch in Time

Mason Jar Mayhem

When There’s a Will

Cast6

Galadriel Stineman

Cheryl Cooper

Denise Gossett

Naomi Miller

Kevin Joy

Levi Miller

Lance E. Nichols

Chief Twitchell

Ryan O'Quinn

Seth Miller

Riley Beeson

Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller

Discussion

0 comments

Join the conversation

Share your take and reply to other fans.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this episode.

Episode Summary

"Simply Vanished" is episode 5 of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries season 1. It scored 7.4/10 from 24 votes, ranking #7 of 8 episodes this season (season average 7.6). It aired on May 21, 2026.

Next: E6 · Stitch in Time Best of Season 1