8.4/101,196 votes#1 - My Old Friend's New Friend
Season 4 Episode 1 - Aired 8/31/2004
Turk and Carla start to have issues when Carla tries to change everything about her new husband. Molly Clock (Heather Graham), the hospital's new psychiatrist, becomes friends with Elliot because she believes Turk, J.D. and Carla are shutting her out. Also, when Turk and J.D.'s car blows up, Carla lets him pick out the new ride only to find that instead of a car, he buys three scooters for them, further proving Carla's point that she needs to always be in control. The episode guest stars the Sugarhill Gang.
Director: Bill Lawrence
Writer: Eric Weinberg
8.1/101,120 votes#2 - My Office
Season 4 Episode 2 - Aired 9/7/2004
Dr. Clock tries to reconcile J.D. and Eliot, while waiting to see which one Dr. Cox will give the Chief Resident position to. Molly and Carla are experiencing some subtle conflict and Elliot and J.D. begin to come together after long bouts of conflict of their own. Meanwhile, Dr. Cox, Turk and the Janitor are forced to work together to help a patient.
Director: Gail Mancuso
Writer: Matt Tarses
8.0/101,108 votes#3 - My New Game
Season 4 Episode 3 - Aired 9/14/2004
Dr. Cox is having issues with Jordan, since Ted revealed that they are still technically married due to some filing problems. J.D. has problems of his own as he can't shake off the tag of Co-Chief Resident the Janitor assigned to him, while Elliot keeps the Chief Resident tag. Elsewhere, Turk begins to doubt his abilities after letting a patient die and isn't helped, when he finds out J.D. has no confidence in him either. Dr. Cox and Molly spar about her involvement in his patients.
Director: Ken Whittingham
Writer: Gabrielle Allan
8.0/101,112 votes#4 - My First Kill
Season 4 Episode 4 - Aired 9/21/2004
J.D. is shocked to hear Dr. Cox tell his interns that eventually, they will screw up and kill a patient. J.D. fears his first time killing someone will soon be upon him. Elliot is upset with Molly, after she disagrees about a patient's promise to attend drug rehab. Carla loses Rowdy and she and the Janitor go looking for him.
Director: Ken Whittingham
Writer: Tad Quill
8.0/101,111 votes#5 - Her Story
Season 4 Episode 5 - Aired 9/28/2004
Elliot becomes unsure, if she wants Molly as her mentor, when she finds out that Molly doesn't have a perfect home life. J.D. is tested in leadership skills when Dr. Cox yells at him in front of his interns. Carla and Turk try to come to an agreement when Turk continuously wakes Carla up every night.
Director: John Inwood
Writer: Angela Nissel
8.8/101,442 votes#6 - My Cake
Season 4 Episode 6 - Aired 10/12/2004
When Dan resurfaces, J.D. is shocked to learn his father has passed away. The reactions from his co-workers help J.D. a little, but the one person, Dr. Cox, who he wanted to be there for him is too busy with J.D.'s patients. Meanwhile, Dan sits drunk in the bath tub the whole day and Turk finds out he has Type II Diabetes.
Director: Henry Chan
Writer: Garrett Donovan, Neil Goldman
7.8/101,116 votes#7 - My Common Enemy
Season 4 Episode 7 - Aired 10/19/2004
When J.D. finds Dan with Elliot, Turk tells him to use the hurt brother excuse to get them to break up, just like Turk uses his diabetes to get stuff from Carla. But then J.D. realizes he wasn't hurt at all... Dr. Cox and Dr. Kelso unite to try and torment their common enemy: Dr. Clock.
Director: Joanna Kerns
Writer: Bill Callahan
8.7/101,369 votes#8 - My Last Chance
Season 4 Episode 8 - Aired 10/26/2004
When Molly takes a job at a different city, she and J.D. end up having a night of kissing, and he tries to rush to sleep with her before she leaves. Dr. Cox goes on ambulance duty with a maniac, who he eventually finds out is a woman who has lost her son to an accident.
Director: Zach Braff
Writer: Mike Schwartz
8.0/101,115 votes#9 - My Malpractical Decision
Season 4 Episode 9 - Aired 11/9/2004
J.D. is approached by a malpractice attorney, asking him to do a risky procedure on her father. Meanwhile, Elliot guides Doug to a new career path and Turk struggles to avoid a hypochondriac patient.
Director: Gail Mancuso
Writer: Janae Bakken
8.1/101,153 votes#10 - My Female Trouble
Season 4 Episode 10 - Aired 11/16/2004
With the case against Turk on his mind, J.D. attempts to end it with Neena, but she won't take "no" for an answer and keeps him wrapped around her finger. Carla tries her own way of persuading Mr. Corman to drop the lawsuit. Elliot sets out to prove she isn't the doctor she was four years ago and doesn't need to rely on anyone anymore.
Director: Chris Koch
Writer: Debra Fordham
8.2/101,297 votes#11 - My Unicorn
Season 4 Episode 11 - Aired 11/23/2004
J.D. takes matters into his own hands, when searching for a relative for his favorite patient. Meanwhile, Elliot is fed up with coworkers not taking her serious and discovers, that she can get her way by flaunting her femininity with some help from Carla and Jordan.
Director: Matthew Perry
Writer: Tad Quill, Gabrielle Allan
8.6/101,297 votes#12 - My Best Moment
Season 4 Episode 12 - Aired 12/7/2004
When J.D. has to address a bunch of pre-med students about what it's like to be a doctor, he strays off the beaten path and chooses to discuss his best moments as a doctor instead. When he challenges the rest of the staff to do so, they all remember their best memories in the medical field. Meanwhile, Elliot is forced to face her fear of children, when she must befriend a ten year old boy, whose father is being treated in the I.C.U.
Director: Chris Koch
Writer: Angela Nissel
7.9/101,074 votes#13 - My Ocardial Infarction
Season 4 Episode 13 - Aired 1/18/2005
Elliot starts showing J.D. up as the calmer, more competent doctor. A date with the Janitor leads to an a capella sing-off between his "group" and Ted's band. Turk starts taking his diabetes more serious, when he realizes the dire consequences of the disease.
Director: Ken Whittingham
Writer: Mark Stegemann
8.2/101,318 votes#14 - My Lucky Charm
Season 4 Episode 14 - Aired 1/25/2005
A man injured in a bar fight teaches Turk and J.D. a lesson about living life to the fullest.
Director: Chris Koch
Writer: Mike Schwartz
8.0/101,074 votes#15 - My Hypocritical Oath
Season 4 Episode 15 - Aired 2/1/2005
J.D. has a crush on a girl, who he met at a club, and he's torn about telling her, that her boyfriend has gonorrhea. Elliot decides to take a stand against Dr. Kelso with one of her patients. And Dr. Cox is blackmailed by the Janitor for a basketball game's score, after he spoils the end of "The Sixth Sense."
Director: Craig Zisk
Writer: Tim Hobert
8.0/101,093 votes#16 - My Quarantine
Season 4 Episode 16 - Aired 2/8/2005
J.D. tries to impress Kylie by paying a hobo in the hospital to fake a heart attack, when everything becomes boring due to a quarantine that he caused. Turk learns, that Carla dated Cox and gets mad at her for not telling him. The Janitor makes a bet with Dr. Kelso, who is starving, that will make him pay $700, unless the Janitor is able to get a "face cake," in order to satisfy him, from Laverne. Also, Danni Sullivan returns to annoy everyone, causing a constant fight between Ted and Doug.
Director: Michael Spiller
Writer: Tad Quill
8.3/101,311 votes#17 - My Life in Four Cameras
Season 4 Episode 17 - Aired 2/15/2005
When J.D. meets a former writer from his all time favorite TV show "Cheers," he begins to picture his life at the hospital as a bland, multiple camera sitcom, where everything is perfect and wraps up nicely. Back in reality, Cox is relunctant to fire an amiable cafeteria worker, while Turk and Carla struggle to keep their promise of constant romantic affection afloat.
Director: Adam Bernstein
Writer: Debra Fordham
8.2/101,075 votes#18 - My Roommates
Season 4 Episode 18 - Aired 2/22/2005
J.D. is thrown out of the apartment. Turk and Carla continue to struggle to keep the romance alive. Dr. Cox has reason to believe that the son of an old buddy is autistic.
Director: Craig Zisk
Writer: Tim Hobert
8.4/101,199 votes#19 - My Best Laid Plans
Season 4 Episode 19 - Aired 3/1/2005
J.D. ditches a seemingly uninterested Kylie for Dr. Molly Clock, who just returned from Milwaukee. Carla fumes over Turk's frequent phone calls to an ex-girlfriend. The Janitor and Dr. Cox make a wager over Elliot.
Director: Zach Braff
Writer: Bill Callahan
8.3/101,114 votes#20 - My Boss's Free Haircut
Season 4 Episode 20 - Aired 3/29/2005
Dr. Kelso dons scrubs to prove a point to Dr. Cox, only to watch it backfire, when an obnoxious patient refuses to listen to him. J.D. and Turk party, while Carla struggles to find solace in Elliot.
Director: John Inwood
Writer: Mark Stegemann
8.0/101,030 votes#21 - My Lips Are Sealed
Season 4 Episode 21 - Aired 4/5/2005
When Carla and J.D. go out to let Carla have some fun, they get drunk and end up accidentally kissing. Dr. Cox gets the hammer dropped by Jordan, when Jack has to get stitches under Perry's watch. Elliot has trouble with a male patient, who has taken enhancement pills.
Director: John Michel
Writer: Janae Bakken
8.2/101,050 votes#22 - My Big Move
Season 4 Episode 22 - Aired 4/12/2005
J.D. and Carla get the silent treatment from Turk, who can't seem to control his emotions, after learning about their kiss. Dr. Cox reluctantly seeks the help of Elliot, when an epileptic patient won't listen to him. The Janitor feels emasculated by his new uniform. Jordan trys Botox.
Director: Victor Nelli Jr.
Writer: Bonnie Sikowitz
7.8/101,047 votes#23 - My Faith in Humanity
Season 4 Episode 23 - Aired 4/19/2005
Turk won't open up at couples therapy. Elliot refuses Dr. Cox's romantic advice, when a very attractive man saunters into the hospital. J.D. learns a lesson in humanity from a dying old woman. The Janitor accidently lets a bunch of rats run around Sacred Heart.
Director: Ken Whittingham
Writer: David Feinberg
7.9/101,025 votes#24 - My Drive-By
Season 4 Episode 24 - Aired 4/26/2005
Elliot is torn between moving too quickly and ruining her new relationship with Jake. Dr. Cox teaches Turk about having a healthy ego and Dr. Kelso and the Janitor fight over who gets to use the motorized cart.
Director: Will Mackenzie
Writer: Angela Nissel
8.0/101,027 votes#25 - My Changing Ways
Season 4 Episode 25 - Aired 5/10/2005
With their residencies over, there are big changes at Sacred Heart. J.D. moves out to live on his own, while Turk and Carla consider a family change, creating another rift in their long friendship. Jordan is hired to handle some paperwork for Kelso, which annoys Cox. Elliot has a job interview at a different hospital thanks to her boyfriend Jake.
Director: Victor Nelli Jr.
Writer: Bill Lawrence
Season 4 Ratings Summary
"My Old Friend's New Friend" is the best rated episode of "Scrubs" season 4. It scored 8.4/10 based on 1196 votes. Directed by Bill Lawrence and written by Eric Weinberg, it aired on 8/31/2004. This episode is rated 0.3 points higher than the second-best, "My Office".